Fitness – Healthy.net https://healthy.net Sun, 15 Sep 2019 16:01:00 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://healthy.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/cropped-Healthy_Logo_Solid_Angle-1-1-32x32.png Fitness – Healthy.net https://healthy.net 32 32 165319808 Ten Years of Self-Care Classes https://healthy.net/2019/08/26/ten-years-of-self-care-classes/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=ten-years-of-self-care-classes Mon, 26 Aug 2019 21:02:35 +0000 https://healthy.net/2019/08/26/ten-years-of-self-care-classes/ [The family doctor who taught the first U.S. self-care class describes that class and the subsequent rapid growth of the self-care movement.]


I always find myself explaining Keith Sehnert as the George Washington of self-care. Keith graduated from Western Reserve School of Medicine in 1953. After working as a General Practitioner and later as Medical Director of Dorsey Laboratories in Lincoln, Nebraska, he joined the Reston-Herndon Medical Center in Herndon, Virginia. There, in 1970, he taught—and largely invented—the first of the modern breed of self-care classes, classes in which laypeople learned basic medical skills formerly reserved for doctors only.

The class drew wide media attention. In 1972, Keith became a visiting professor at Georgetown University and in 1974 founded the Center for Continuing Health Education at Georgetown.

The Center for Continuing Health Education did self-care research, taught health professionals from all parts of the country to conduct self-care classes, and prepared course materials for these classes. In 1977, Keith became Vice President and Director of the Health Promotion Group at InterStudy, a health-policy and health-futures think tank in the Minneapolis area, and joined the University of Minnesota School of Public Health as clinical professor.

It is in large part because of Keith’s efforts that there are now self-care classes in forty states. He is the author of How to Be Your Own Doctor (Sometimes).


TF: You were saying that you were a student of Ben Spock’s at Western Reserve.

KS: Yes, back in the early fifties. Spock was just starting out as a teacher there, and his book, Baby and Child Care (reviewed on page 207) was just out. Of course, no one had any idea then it was going to become so popular.


Did he have a big influence on you?

He did. He was very concerned that most patients were getting a great deal of treatment but very little teaching. He felt that was a mistake.


I don’t think there’s any doubt but that his book planted a seed for me. I’ve always thought of my book as a kind of Dr. Spock for adults.


Were there any other experiences at Reserve that nudged you in the direction” of self-care?

Yes, the influence of another very important teacher, T. Hale Ham. In those days the whole business of a doctor’s empathy for the patient and communication skills were spoken of as one’s bedside manner. We were all very concerned about our bedside manner. Dr. Ham used to say, “Keith, you just talk to your patients in whatever way is most comfortable to you—but keep in mind that if you’re a good teacher, your patients will think you’re a good doctor.”


How did you happen to end up teaching that first self-care class?

Well, you know, serendipity plays such a big part in these things. I’d just joined a family practice group in the Reston area of Virginia. The guy who’d actually planned the class was leaving to join the Family Practice Department at the University of Wisconsin. One day he just casually asked me, ” Look, as long as you’re going to be here, would you mind picking this thing up for me?” And of course I said yes.


How many students were there?

I think there were forty, maybe forty-two. About 80 percent women. Almost all of them were patients at the Medical Center.


What was the first class meeting like?

It was an interesting experience. Many of the people in the first class were women whose husbands had been recently laid off by a reduction in the Johnson administration space program. Some of them were living on unemployment insurance for the first time in their lives.

As we got to know each other better, a lot of anger toward the health-care system started to come up. Frustrating experiences. Times when they’d been treated insensitively.

The old authoritarian doctor image was hanging over our heads, even though I wasn’t the typical authoritarian doctor. There was a lot of asking, is this something that’s okay to talk about? Is it all right for me to ask this question? And when I made it very clear that it was, they really began to share their experiences and concerns. They began to express feelings they may never have expressed to anyone before—certainly never to a physician.

It soon became clear that they had a lot of health needs that weren’t being met by the health-care system. They’d been put down and ripped off. The women’s movement was beginning to be active around that time, and the women especially were beginning to look at their lives in some new ways.

Pretty soon people started saying, “Why can’t I take my father’s blood pressure?” “Why can’t I give my kids allergy shots?” “Why can’t I use an otoscope to look in my little boy’s ear when he has an earache?”

And I found myself saying, “I don’t know why not. Let’s do it.” So the whole course evolved out of the things people were asking.


Had there been any other similar classes up to that time?

No, to my knowledge, it was the first class of its kind. There had been orientation tours for new patients in certain clinics and patient education for some specific diseases like diabetes, but nobody had ever really gotten into this area before.


How would you define this new area?

1 think of it as directed toward a new kind of medical consumer, what I call the activated patient. In my Herndon class, their questions went well beyond the boundaries of what had been thought of as patient education at that time. They wanted to know why they couldn’t have their own black bags of medical tools at home. No one had ever thought of teaching laypeople to use such tools before. There weren’t any models for that. So we just had to go along and figure out how to do it as best we could.


What motivates a person to take a self-care class?

We’ve looked at that, and there seem to be seven basic reasons people give, over and over, for their interest in self-care:

    1. wanting to save money on health expenses;

    2. wanting to be able to take better care of their family’s health, to be able to make effective family-health decisions;

    3. wanting to take more responsibility for their own illness care—like hypertensives who want to be able to keep track of their own blood pressure;

    4. wanting to learn how to hook into the medical system like a number of older people who outlived their doctors and weren’t able to find a new one they were satisfied with;

    5. wanting to learn more about their bodies and how they work;

    6. people with illness in the family, wanting to feel more confident in dealing with it;

    7. people who’ve gotten turned on to healthier life styles, wanting to hear more about jogging, nutrition, yoga, meditation, and whatever else there might be to this whole healthy lifestyle business.

So you include more than just traditional Western medicine in your classes?

Oh, yes. Of the really alternative approaches to health, yoga is the main one we’ve used—mainly because a neighbor of mine happened to be a fine yoga teacher. If I’d lived next door to a Thai chi teacher, we might have included that. The introduction to yoga has certainly been well-accepted by our students.

I think giving these kinds of alternatives is awfully important, particularly because through them people can learn to get the same kinds of things they might now be getting from alcohol and various other chemicals. And those are not ways I like to see people relieve their stress.


How long did the Course for Activated Patients go on?

We ran two classes a year for almost three years. Then, in February of 1973, Howard Eisenberg did a story on the class for Parade magazine, and I got over two thousand letters as a result. That made me realize that what we were up to might be something with a much wider appeal than I’d thought.

About that time I began getting inquiries from the federal Department of Health, Education and Welfare, from a number of foundations, and from several of the faculty and deans who were interested in doing something more in the way of self-care at Georgetown University.

Several publishers started wining and dining me and convinced me that there was a need for a book on what we were doing. So I took a six-month sabbatical and collaborated with Howard Eisenberg on How to Be Your Own Doctor (Sometimes). Shortly after that, the Center for Continuing Health Education was formed at Georgetown, and I became its director.


So you were there until 1977?

Yes. Then our grant ran out, and the functions of the Center were divided between the Health Activated Person Program at the Georgetown School of Nursing, where they’re continuing to give an ongoing self-care course for the Washington community, and the Health Activation Network (see page 268), who put out a newsletter, “The Health Activation News,” to train self-care teachers and help people establish new courses.


You know, Keith, I have a feeling that if it had been some other doctor teaching that class, it might have ended up as just a lot of boring lectures. Have you had special training in communication, or are you just good at it?

Well, as you know, one of my daughters, Cindy, is deaf, and that’s made me very aware of the importance of getting and giving feedback. It got me very interested in good communications, and when I was talking to a patient I would always give and ask for feedback to be sure we were understanding each other.

And then the other thing was how much I loved doing it. I discovered that I liked being a facilitator better than being an authority. There was a feeling of real partnership. It was wonderful to relax out of my professional role and, if somebody asked me a question, to say, “1 don’t know. How do you suppose we’d go about finding out?”


It was a very rare thing in my medical education to hear a doctor say, “I don’t know.”

Incredibly rare. We were taught we were supposed to know all the answers.

How have health professionals reacted to self-care classes?

I like to say, scratch a doctor and you’ll find a teacher underneath. Most doctors have been too busy with day-to-day practice to develop as teachers, but once they do it, they find that it’s fun.

I’ve brought a lot of health professionals into selfcare classes, and while at times I’ve had to more or less drag them kicking and screaming into the pit, once they take off the white coat, loosen the tie, and get their shoes off, they find they’re having a fine time. It’s a real relief to be able to show your human side, and the people in the classes are always so appreciative.

There’s a real sense of working together for a common goal. Most of us went into medicine for pretty altruistic reasons. We’re not all dollar-sign guys. And when you start relating to people as active partners instead of passive pawns, they really appreciate it, and they let the doctor know.


In my medical school training, except for a little bit in psychiatry, I didn’t receive any formal training in communicating with patients. Many people would say that medical education makes doctors less capable of communicating on a meaningful level. Are there any signs that this is changing?

Well, coincidentally, I just finished reading a report on self-care from the Association of American Medical Colleges. They’re getting together a major project in which they will begin teaching self-care communication skills in a number of medical schools. Dr. James Hudson is going to be the Project director.

The American Medical Students Association also has modest self-care programs going at a number of medical schools. And of course there are all kinds of new and fairly informal projects at individual schools—there’s something here at the University of Minnesota Medical School, the University of Arizona has one, as does Georgetown University. There’s a big interest at UC Berkeley, and you were just telling me about the self-care class you visited at Wright State School of Medicine in Dayton. There’s actually quite a lot going on in the medical schools already.


Any signs of health insurance companies being willing to reimburse policy holders for self-care education expenses?

Blue Cross of Montana has started doing this on a very small scale, and some of the other Blue Cross plans have been saying they’re going to get into this area— they’re putting on some prevention education programs now. Several other insurance companies are looking into self-care education. International Group Health in Washington has started several projects. IGP’s head guy, Jim Gibbons, is a real self-care advocate.


Could you comment on the kinds of people who are—and should be—teaching self-care classes?

I’ve always felt that the ideal teacher was the nurse. Certainly the greatest enthusiasm for self-care has come from nurses, nurse practitioners, and physicians’ assistants. Many of these allied health professionals feel much more strongly about prevention and self-care than about diagnosis and treatment—which continues to be the main concern of most physicians.


Do you think it’s important for the people teaching these classes to have clinical experience?

It certainly helps. One of the real dilemmas these days is that people hear this from Reader’s Digest, that from the National Inquirer, and something else from Prevention. They need to be able to ask someone who has done more than just read the books.


How about in the schools? Do you think it would be an advantage to include people with clinical experience as a part of health-education classes?

Yes. Not only are clinical workers more likely to have experience with these matters, but it’d be very valuable for kids to be able to talk to a health worker at some time other than when they’re sick or need shots.


Do you see a connection between the widespread popularity of running and the developing self-care movement?

Absolutely. Because as people start feeling better from jogging, and begin to sleep better and eat better, they’re going to discover they have more energy than they ever did before. Then they begin to realize that health is a resource to be conserved, not something you can waste and then discard like a cigarette butt or a wrecked car.


Yes. Your body is a temple. Why treat it like a motel?

Yes, that’s a good one. So when people increase their nutritional awareness, or start jogging, or get into stress reduction, they feel better. And taken they say, “Well, gee, maybe I can kick smoking and kick alcohol and practice a healthier lifestyle. And it’ll pay off.” And it does!


What other cultural changes are we likely to see?

One we’re already seeing is a change in men’s thinking and behavior. For so long we’ve had this macho male image about everything that’s harmful or illegal.

If I smoke and it’s bad for me, I must really enjoy it. It’s a sort of bad-boy mentality. To have fun, you’ve got to be destructive—driving too fast, abusing your body or those of people around you.

That tough-guy mentality is softening. As I go into groups of my peers—men in their late forties or early fifties—I find I seldom hear the sort of thing which was the rule not very many years ago. You know, ” Boy, did we have a good time last night. I bet old Fred and I drank a fifth of booze . . .” and so on. That kind of bragging.

Now I’ll more likely hear a guy say, “You know, I’m so proud of myself. I finally quit smoking after twenty-two years.” And everyone is very interested in how he did it. They’re talking about jogging and cutting down on their drinking.


I had some unpleasant experiences—before going to medical school—when I tried to find certain health information in a medical library. It would have been much easier to look for comparable information in just about any other field—engineering, physics, biology. But technical medical information—for someone who is not a medical professional—is almost impossible to come by.

I recently called the National Arthritis Foundation to ask how our readers could order copies of a book they put out. It covers arthritic diseases in depth, it’s comprehensive, and it’s cheap—one of the best available sources of information on arthritis. I was told that it wasn’t available to laypeople, ”because they might misunderstand it. ” A medical librarian at Yale told me that she had been taught to discourage laypeople who came into the medical library in search of information, “because it was probably somebody looking for evidence for a malpractice suit. ” Why is medical information kept so secret?

Until recently, the medical mystique was much like the religious mystique in the days of Martin Luther and the Protestant Reformation—the language of the laity was one world and the language of the clergy was another. They didn’t even say their prayers in the same language. It was a priesthood. There were things that the layperson wasn’t supposed to know about.

I think that what we’re seeing now, with the demystification of medical language, is comparable to the change Luther made in bringing Christianity into the language of the people.

That’s the most important thing that happens in these self-care classes. First, you let people know that it’s okay for them to step into this formerly forbidden area, and second, you guide them in their first steps. So the main thing is not the class itself, but the fact that it can get people started. It’s a perceptual door opener.

It should be the goal of every health professional to transfer useful and accurate tools, skills, and knowledge to his or her clients. To hide these “professional secrets” and keep them for one’s own aggrandizement is a malfunction of one’s professional role.


One last question, Keith. Would you look into your crystal ball and share your thoughts about the kinds of changes we’re going to see in the next ten years as a result of the growing enthusiasm for self-care?

When I first moved to Minnesota last year, I picked up a paper and saw that a man was considering running for governor on a health-promotion platform. I think we’re going to see mayors and governors and other political leaders picking this up—and probably in your state of California, too. I think self-care will be one of the big political issues of the next decade—in the way that education and agricultural reform and honesty in government have been hot political issues.

A second thing is that the business community is going to get increasingly involved in health promotion, self-care, and helping their employees become wiser buyers and wiser users of health-care services. The big corporations especially are feeling the pain of rising health-benefits costs. In fact, the guys bathe executive suites are hitting the ceiling. These decision-makers are suddenly realizing that health insurance premiums, disability insurance, early retirement, days lost from work due to illness, are all things they can do something about. Several companies last year paid more for health benefits than they did for any other product or service. So I think we’re going to see a lot of self-care promotion on the part of industry.

Third, I think a lot of leadership in this area is going to come from senior citizens. I think that women will continue to be especially active in self-care, and I think we’ll begin to see unions taking a major role.

Fourth, we’re going to see school systems putting in really high-quality self-care programs running all the way from kindergarten to high school. There are some exciting things happening along such lines in Maine, Montana, and Minnesota schools already.

And finally, I think we’re going to see a growing number of fitness/self-care/health-promotion groups, health-information centers, health clubs, self-care classes and study groups, alternative health centers, stop-smoking clinics, and exercise facilities, more widely available black-bag tools, and so on.

]]>
23622
A Field Guide to Body Work https://healthy.net/2019/08/26/a-field-guide-to-body-work/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=a-field-guide-to-body-work Mon, 26 Aug 2019 21:02:35 +0000 https://healthy.net/2019/08/26/a-field-guide-to-body-work/ A couple of years ago, I was attending a conference in Berkeley and a friend pointed out a man in the crowd. “I wonder who he is,” – she said. “Boy, does he look healthy.” It turned out to be Ken Dychtwald.

Ken first began investigating the relationship between the body and the mind while constructing biofeedback instruments as an undergraduate electrical engineering student. Not long after that, he visited the Esalen institute in Big Sur as a participant in a body work seminar. As part of the course, the group leader made a careful examination of his body and then, without asking him a single question, went on to tell him about his relationship with his mother and father, described his attitudes toward life, love, relationships, movement, change, and performance, and outlined his major personality strengths and weaknesses.

“Everything he said, every observation he made, was entirely correct,” Ken remembers. “I was amazed. How did he do it? How could he possibly know so much about my feelings and experiences by looking at my body? I’d revealed none of my personal life to him.

”There was only one possible explanation—somehow my body was presenting him with information that he was noticing and reading back to me. This simple, yet profound, experience convinced me that I was going to have to put some serious effort into studying the relationship between the body and the mind.”

Ken spent the next ten years in an intense study of body work. These explorations have included the study of yoga, t’ai chi, bioenergetics, acupuncture, physical fitness, and massage. He also obtained a Ph.D. in psychology and, combining all these interests, he wrote the book Bodymind. Many of the concepts explored in our conversation are expanded further in his book.

Ken has served as the co-director of SAGE, a program aimed at helping older people find ways to lead healthful, fulfilled lives. He is now president of the National Association for Humanistic Gerontology and an advisory editor of Medical Self-Care Magazine.

TF: How did you happen to leave college to study at the Esalen Institute?

KD: By the end of my junior year, that was 1970, I’d read every book on awareness, growth, and body work I could find. The authors of many of the best books turned out to be at Esalen. It was clear to me that something new was going on out there that wasn’t happening on my campus. I decided to go right to the source. It was probably the smartest thing I ever did. I spent six months at Esalen, taking dozens of workshops—yoga workshops, encounter workshops, massage workshops, sensitivity workshops, t’ai chi workshops.

You were also saying that Maslow’s book, Toward a Psychology of Being, was a very, important one for you around that time.

Yes. It’s a great book. It provided the whole context within which I was starting to think. It talks about life as being a continuum, with sickness and problems on one end and creativity and vitality, aliveness and brilliance on the other. Maslow suggests that we should experience ourselves as including that whole continuum. We are both the problems and the brilliance. He talks about a kind of growth in which we come to accept both. He calls this kind of acceptance “actualization.” I would recommend that book to anyone interested in body work or personal growth.

Another important book was Will Schutz’s Joy. It spoke of honesty and sensitivity and authenticity. It was a very revolutionary book when it came out in 1967. Since then these ideas have been widely accepted in education and religion and psychology.

Fritz Perls’ books, too Gestalt Therapy Verbatim and In and Out of the Garbage Pail. I really liked his notion of seeing yourself as a whole variety of sometimes disharmonious parts in relation to each other. And working with the separate parts to achieve a more integrated state.

What were the main ideas that the work at Esalen was based on?

I thought of them as realizations. One of the main ones was self-responsibility. I realized that I was responsible for myself to a much, much larger extent than I’d ever imagined. It soon became very clear that I was making choices in the way I breathed and the way I got sick and the way I perceived other people. I learned that I had many more alternatives than I had realized. I began to discover a much greater degree of freedom in my life than anyone had ever led me to believe.

Somehow, up to then, I’d picked up the belief that I wasn’t really empowered in my own right. That I needed to depend on my parents and my teachers and other kinds of “experts.” It was an amazing realization to discover that I was really at the root of my own life. It was pretty shattering, too, because I had to assume responsibility for a lot of situations I’d been blaming on other people and on institutions. On the other hand, I suddenly felt immensely powerful, almost godlike. I realized that if I chose to work on it, I could run a marathon, raise my IQ, learn to control my heartbeat—to do all kinds of things I’d never let myself believe I might be able to do.

What were some other realizations?

Another significant one was seeing the ways in which the mind and body were so intimately involved—like dancing partners. The mind really wasn’t separate from the body. Thinking and feeling and perceiving didn’t take place in some little box behind the eyes, as I’d always believed. My mind was present in every cell in my body. That was why the group leader in that early body work group had been able to read out my whole character. It was all there! I got so I could tell a great deal about a person by seeing them stand or sit or walk.

I learned that stress and emotional tension can become focused in a specific part of the body, and that if this happens over a long period of time it will permanently shape the person’s posture so that every movement will express that pattern. And the parts of the body in which emotions are trapped will be the parts most likely to develop malfunctions. For example, if a person needs to cry, but won’t let himself, he may stop the crying by clinching his jaw. If the jaw is held tightly, over a long period, chronic tension is likely to develop in the tempero-mandibular joint or grinding of the teeth or headaches. Or unexpressed anger, trapped in the abdomen, can lead to a wide variety of disorders.

So illness can come from unexpressed emotions.

Yes, and the opposite is also true. If a person in creative or unusually vital or energetic, it’s not just a matter of genetics or blind luck, it’s a result of choices—conscious or unconscious—that he or she is making every day.

So, the body isn’t just a static object, but a constantly-changing, pliable organism.

Yes. We are constantly in process. Our bodies are constantly being shaped by the choices we do—or don’t—make. We can passively let things go on as they are, or we can choose to make changes. I can notice that certain joints are tight and do yoga to loosen them up. If I’m feeling tense and scattered, I can meditate and actually change the kinds of brain waves I’m generating. If I’m having difficulty in personal relationships, I can get feedback from friends on my personal style of relating to people and try some new alternatives. I create myself with the choices I make every day.

So that’s what you started doing at Esalen.

Yes. I started noticing what kinds of choices made me feel good and what choices made me feel unwell. Later, when I started working as a therapist, I tried to help other people learn how to make similar kinds of choices, to design their own lives healthfully. I found that there was a real hunger for tools and skills of physical and psychological self-care.

Why do you think we are seeing this sudden interest in self-responsibility?

I think that a lot of us, whether we’re psychologists or housewives or shoe salesmen, are discovering that we’re not as healthy and fulfilled as we had dreams of being. A lot of people are discovering that giving all your faith and power to your doctor isn’t going to make you any healthier. The feeling that “I don’t know anything about my health and I don’t want to know,” which has been the predominant attitude in this culture, is really changing. People are realizing that an authoritarian medical system in which patients give over all their power to the doctors and function as though they’re deaf, dumb, and blind just isn’t meeting their needs. People are ready to take back a good deal of that power. People want to take care of themselves. And I think that the various kinds of body work are a big part of that.

What are the main approaches to body work?

One useful way of getting your bearings in the field of body work is to group kinds of body work by the general approach. Let me outline ten general kinds of self-care skills in the field of body work:

    1. developing muscular strength and tone;

    2. developing aerobic fitness;

    3. developing flexibility:

    4. developing relaxation skills;

    5. developing breathing skills;

    6. developing neuromuscular coordination;

    7. using massage to develop sensory awareness and to fulfill our need to be touched;

    8. working on emotions through the body;

    9. using the mind to influence the body;

    10. using the body to center the mind.
    Of course, there’s a great deal of overlap among these ten general approaches.

Developing muscular strength—would that be something like weight lifting?

Yes. That’s one specific way. Pushups, swimming, tennis, basketball, housework, walking, running—any activity that uses the muscles. Anything that makes us really exert ourselves. Muscles that aren’t used get flabby and lose their tone. In addition, it’s important to remember that all the muscles in the body need to be developed in a balanced way. So activities that use a broad range of muscles are the best.

I’d like to ask you, as you go along, to suggest some of the best books for each of the ten approaches.

Sure. For developing muscular strength, the best overall- book is The East-West Exercise Book, by David Smith. General approach number two is developing aerobic fitness, building up the heart as a muscle. It’s a very valuable addition to an exercise program to get a stethoscope and just spend some time listening to your heart. And, of course, monitoring your pulse is an important part of such a program.

In developing an aerobics program, it’s important to remember that you need to perform a vigorous activity such as running, swimming, rowing, or rope jumping—wherein your body is exerting itself to 75 percent of its maximum pulse rate for at least fifteen minutes at least three times a week.

Two other excellent books on improving the health of your heart are Type A Behavior and Your Heart and The American Way of Life Need Not Be Dangerous to Your Health. The best book on aerobics exercise programs is The Aerobics Way, by Kenneth Cooper.

The third category on your list was developing flexibility.

This is where activities like yoga come in. Hatha yoga is a system of postures and exercises designed to gently stretch and tone all the muscles of the body. Yoga works to systematically lengthen, vitalize, and integrate the muscles of the body and to improve circulation and glandular nervous system function. It not only makes you more flexible, but it serves as a means of centering meditation as well.

Four beginning yoga books that many people have found helpful are Richard Hittelman’s Guide to Yoga, The Light of Yoga Society’s Beginner’s Manual, Jess Steam’s Yoga, Youth, and Reincarnation, and Swami Vishnu Devananda’s The Complete Illustrated Book of Yoga. A good introduction for older people is provided in Easy Does It Yoga for People Over 60. My favorite introduction to the philosophies behind doing yoga is Joel Kramer’s The Passionate Mind. And the very best advanced book on yoga is the classic by B. K. S. Iyengar, Light on Yoga (revised edition).

You also list relaxation skills as an approach to body work.

Few people are really good at voluntarily relaxing their bodies. As the stress of modern life increases, it becomes essential that we learn relaxation skills and take the time to practice them regularly. One of the pioneers in relaxation training was Edmund Jacobson. His system is called progressive relaxation. It’s described in his book You Must Relax!—I’ve always thought that was a pretty funny title. Another system of relaxation training is autogenics. It’s well described in Norman Shealy’s book 90 Days to Self-Health. There’s also a good cassette tape, Autogenic Training, by Vera Fryling, and a good anthology of approaches to relaxation is John White and James Fadiman’s Relax. My favorite book on preventing stress is Ken Pelletier’s Mind as Healer, Mind as Slayer.

Another approach you cite is developing breathing skills.

Paying attention to breathing is one of the most underrated approaches to body work. The air we breathe gives us life, yet most of us use only 20 to 30 percent of our lung capacity. We’ve used deep breathing exercises with older people at SAGE, and we’ve found that when people begin to breathe more deeply, their bodies and minds become revitalized. They become more alert and alive. Depression and anxiety often fall away.

Breathing exercises can also help you relax. Working on breathing can be a way to get more deeply in touch with feelings, too. People who are tense and depressed tend to breathe shallowly. A person in a relaxed, joyful state will automatically breathe more deeply.

The best practical book on breathing skills I know of is Breathe Away Your Tension, by Bruno Geba.

Describe what you mean by neuromuscular coordination as an approach to body work.

As we grow up, we learn to walk and to move in certain ways, and then, in early adulthood, our neuromuscular development diminishes and, unless we become dancers or acrobats, we fall into a few familiar patterns of moving our bodies. Many kinds of exercises, like running, involve the repetition of a limited range of movements and therefore leave much to be desired in the way of developing our full neuromuscular capacities. These approaches either encourage us to perform common, everyday movements in new ways or to move in some totally new ways. Improvisational dance and Feldenkrais exercises are two good examples of such approaches.

You can make up your own ways of doing new things with your body, too, like cleaning the house or washing the dishes with your other hand. Or learning to write with your nondominant hand. Or your toes. Or blindfolding yourself and exploring the world using only your other senses. Anything that takes you out of your normal patterns of muscular or sensory activity can be considered valid body work.

These approaches try to get your mind out of a rut. For examples, runners can experiment with adding play, movement, and dance to their regular run. Try running at varying speeds or sideways. Or backward. Of course, there are other sports, like basketball, that require constant improvisation. Aikido, a noncombat form of the martial arts, requires constant improvisation. It’s a good example of high-level training in neuromuscular sophistication. So is playing a musical instrument.

What are some good books in this area?

Two books by Moishe Feldenkrais, Awareness Through Movement and The Case of Norah, and Mabel Ellsworth Todd’s The Thinking Body. A good book on dance is Sweigard’s Human Movement Potential.

Approach number seven is massage.

In massage, one person uses his or her hands to touch and manipulate the body of another. There are many types of massage. Ideally, massage will accomplish several major goals.

Receiving a massage is an excellent way to become comfortable being touched by another person. This sounds pretty elementary, but for many of us, being touched in a nonsexual, caring fashion is not a usual part of our daily lives.

Light massage can facilitate relaxation and stimulate the sensory nervous system. Deeper massage can actually release the tension in our muscles. All kinds of massage can increase circulation and glandular functioning and promote a greater sense of well-being and aliveness.

The best overall how-to-get started book on massage is George Downing’s The Massage Book. Another book that does a nice job of summarizing the importance of being touched for our development and well-being is Ashley Montagu’s Touching.

The eighth approach is working on emotions through the body.

Emotions live in the body, and if they’re not allowed to express themselves, they may become lodged in the body as tension. Many of these approaches make uses of expressive activities in order to relieve the body of stress, frustration, and unresolved feelings. For example, instead of just stretching, you might stretch and scream or yell or make faces. Or you might hit a pillow or kick the floor to release tension. Or you might have a pretend fight with someone using Doffers kind of big, well-padded bat.

In some approaches, like bioenergetics, a therapist manipulates different areas while you focus on the memories and feelings that come up as the tension in the various parts of the body is released.

Nearly all the emotion-focused kinds of body work have grown out of the work of Wilhelm Reich. Rolling, Reichian energetics, Postural Integration, Radix, neoReichian therapies, bioenergetics, gestalt therapy, sensory awareness—these are some examples of body work methods that deal with feelings. Reich’s big contribution was the idea that when emotions lodge in the body, they can distort the body’s structure and impair its function. He then found that it was possible for these emotions to be released, leaving the individual not only feeling better but less susceptible to illness.

Would you recommend any books by Reich himself?

Probably not to start with. Reading Reich is like reading the Torah. There are some good books about Reich, though. Boadella’s book, Wilhelm Reich, The Evolution of His Work, is the best biography. Man in the Trap, by Elsworth Baker, is the best book on his clinical practice, and Bioenergetics, by Alexander Lowen, is a good introduction to Reichian thought. Then, and only then, for a general introduction to Reich’s own writings, I’d suggest The Selected Writings of Wilhelm Reich.

How about number nine, using the mind to influence the body?

In recent years there’s been a growing appreciation for the ways in which the mind can influence the functioning of the body. While most mind-body relationships take place outside of our conscious awareness, we can learn to train our minds to influence our bodies in positive, healing ways.

If you close your eyes and imagine that you’re getting beaten up, your mind will generate one kind of body state. If you imagine that you’re making love, it’ll generate another.

If I asked you to imagine that you’re lying on a warm, sunny beach on a quiet tropical island, your body would probably become more relaxed. Obviously, by choosing certain kinds of visualizations and following certain kinds of suggestions, you can put your body into various states. Some of these states can be useful for relaxing or for healing. Some techniques that make use of this approach are biofeedback, autogenics, selfhypnosis, and visualization.

A good book on visualization is Samuels and Samuels’ Seeing With the Mind’s Eye. Some others on influencing the body through the mind are Mind as Healer, Mind as Slayer, by Ken Pelletier, and The Mind /Body Effect, by Herbert Benson.

That brings us to the last category using the body to center the mind.

In these approaches, the idea is to focus the body in such a way so that the mind becomes quiet and clear. Just as stress and unwellness in the body can generate confusion in the mind, stillness in the body can help to produce a deep state of peace of mind.

Probably the most well-known of these approaches is meditation in its various forms. These approaches involve sitting in an alert stillness in order to develop a very centered, transpersonal aspect of the mind. Some of the approaches to mental centering are phrased in religious language. Others are strictly secular. Yogis and meditators have been practicing these kinds of disciplines for years, but contemporary science has only become aware of them recently.

Herbert Benson’s The Relaxation Response is a good overview of meditative approaches. Probably the best how-to-do-it books are Lawrence LeShan’s How to Meditate and Ken Pelletier’s Mind as Healer, Mind as Slayer (again). A favorite is Chogyam Trungpa’s Meditation in Action.

Body work covers a big area!

It certainly does. For some people, body work means yoga. For others, dance. For others, sports or massage. The best thing for you may be to sit quietly in a peaceful place for a long time. For me it may be yelling and laughing and hitting pillows.

The fact that there’s no “right way” has made my work in this field very exciting. Instead of some set of rules to follow, there’s a real freedom to explore. There are many, many ways for us to develop our bodies and our minds. All the books I’ve mentioned are ultimately talking about the same thing—each of us has our own unique path to happiness and fulfillment.

]]>
23626
Human Potential: From Esalen to Mainstreet https://healthy.net/2019/08/26/human-potential-from-esalen-to-mainstreet/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=human-potential-from-esalen-to-mainstreet Mon, 26 Aug 2019 21:02:31 +0000 https://healthy.net/2019/08/26/human-potential-from-esalen-to-mainstreet/ George Leonard is the former senior editor of Look magazine. Considered by some to be the “grandfather” of the human potential movement, Leonard is author of “Mastery”, “The Silent Pulse,” The Transformation,” and along with Esalen co-founder Michael Murphy, “The Life We’ve Been Given.” An aikido master, he has taught Leonard Energy Training, (L.E.T.) to thousands of individuals around the world.


DiCarlo: Please describe the origins of the human potential movement… What was your involvement and what sparked your interest in the exploration of human potential?


Leonard: In the mid-60s, I was a senior editor at Look Magazine, one of the most prestigious and award-winning magazines of its day. I was also west coast editorial manager and I had done lots of award-winning feature articles on education, starting in 1956 with “What is A Teacher?” I did a piece in 1964 called “Revolution in Education”. In the last paragraph I said something about “human potential”. As a result, we must have received at least one hundred letters from readers, which essentially said, “That’s what we really need to do, focus upon the human potential.” It occurred to me put in a request to do an article on the human potential and my request was granted.


Those were the golden days of journalism. Look writers had total authority to do anything they wanted to do. So I began criss-crossing the country. When I was finished I had interviewed 37 experts on the subject of the human potential. Psychiatrists, psychologists, brain researchers-even theologians and philosophers. Not one of them said we were using more than 10% of our capacity. In later years, I came to realize that was a very conservative estimate-we’re using about 1% I would guess. Maybe less.


During the 7 months in which I was criss-crossing the country, I had heard something about Michael Murphy and this little institute called Esalen in Big Sur, California, the programs of which ran under the banner, “Human Potentialities.” When I finally had the opportunity to meet Michael, we hit it off immediately. We went to the house of a woman we both knew to have dinner. After we had left, we kept on talking, till three in the morning. We’ve been talking ever since. I met Mike February 2, 1965 and it changed my life.


He was really into the subject of human potential and we had what you might call a dovetailing of interests. I knew quite a bit about various social movements, such as the civil rights movement, I covered that story from Little Rock, right on through Selma and Ole Mist-the whole thing. I also knew a lot about brain research and behavioral psychology from the work I had been doing on this human potential article. Mike was very well versed on Eastern philosophy and religion, humanistic psychology and some of the more frontier developments of the day, such as biofeedback. So when we started exchanging stories, everything seemed to go together. It made a complete picture. So we just immediately started brainstorming, saying what could we both do and what should be done. A number of the events of that time indicated to us that some sort of transformation really wanted to happen. Of course these were the 60s when such things seemed imminent. So we would just toss out ideas, which I would scrawl down on a piece of paper and throw onto the floor. The accumulated paper looked like a snowstorm, we were throwing so many things. At one point I said, “How about this….we’ve got a civil rights movement and we’ve got a free speech movement…how about a human potential movement?” So I just wrote it down and threw it on the floor. I guess that was the beginning of it.


We started talking about the human potential movement almost jokingly. And that was about the same time the national media discovered Esalen. I never did a story in Look specifically on Esalen, because I thought, “Maybe I’m too close to this and maybe I shouldn’t do it. Maybe somebody else should do it.” Sure enough, by 1967 and 68, the media was in full force, and they picked up the term “human potential movement.” About four years later, Mike and I looked around and said, “My God, this is not what we had in mind at all.” In the beginning, like a child who is attracted to the brightest toy on the floor, the media was fixated upon the mixed baths, hot tubs and encounter groups. So they assumed that the human potential movement must have a lot to do with people getting into hot tubs and crying or yelling things at each other. So we said, “Let’s un-name this movement.” We told others there was no such thing as the human potential movement. But we found that it’s much harder to un-name a movement than it is to name it.


Over the years we have come to accept it, and actually it’s a wonderful term. What we had in mind was not just the emotional side of human experience. We had the idea of integral transformation-of mind, body, soul and heart- from the very beginning. So that’s how the human potential movement started.

DiCarlo: In light of the many years you have been at the leading edge of the human potential movement, I’m wondering if you can help put things into their proper persepctive. More specifically, how have the 60s, 70s, 80s and 90s set the stage for the new paradigm which is now emerging?


Leonard: First of all, I must say that a lot of people don’t want to take a look back at the 60s. All the big 60s books really haven’t sold well. We still haven’t come to terms with that decade. I think that many people are still afraid of the 60s and the ideas that were presented. Some people think the 60s were a period in parenthesis-a decade that really didn’t count-when our whole culture suddenly got out of step. But I don’t think that’s true. I think the activity of the 60s was a very much needed and long overdue reaction and at certain times over-reaction, to years, decades, and centuries of repressiveness and injustice. In think what the 60s basically did was set the agenda for necessary change that we still haven’t gotten around to. And I’m hoping the 90s can be a time when we get to work on that agenda.


Look at all the things that came up in the 60s-the whole idea of ethnicity, race, of gender. The women’s movement. The gay movement. The environmental movement. All of those things began in the 1960s. There was a sudden sunburst before the powers-that-be reacted by clamping down on much of it. There was a counter-60s movement. To use a body metaphor, it is true that many of us during those years were kind of short sighted, but we were literally ahead of ourselves. And a lot of things were done without too much wisdom. But it was a very euphoric and crazy time that clearly and powerfully set the agenda for change.


The 1970s, on the other hand, was a period of what I would call “cultural diffusion.” The ideas that had been circulating around college campuses-mostly in certain enclaves on both coasts but also scattered throughout various pockets in the country-began to diffuse throughout the whole culture. Some of the ideas were better absorbed than others. The sexual revolution, according to Yankalovich surveys in the late 70s, was the most pervasive. Certain sexual practices that were only being promulgated by hippies and the like on the West Coast began to show up wildly throughout the culture- in Des Moines and in Texarcana-wherever you wanted to look. Many have said, “Well, these ideas were co-opted. They have lost some of their fine purity.” Well, that’s OK. Compromise is part of change. But there was a tremendous cultural diffusion.


Also, the 70s was a period of rationalization and commercialization of a lot of good practices. Organizations like “est” took ideas from gestalt therapy and Zen, and so forth, and packaged it very neatly and put it out in hotel ballrooms. I think those organizations probably did more good than harm. But here again, it was a little too pro-forma, it was a little too pat. Of course some people who wouldn’t go to Esalen might go to a hotel ballroom where they could still wear their coat and tie where they could see there was another world and that other possibilities could exist. And we really are a bizarre culture in not recognizing these other spiritual possibilities that have been our birthright since the human race became human. Humankind emerged on this planet with vision, with tremendous vision of an unseen world, of a spiritual realm that held meaning and guidance for us all. The consequences of lack of vision are quite clear- “Where there is no vision the people perish” as the bible says. So all these things were part of the cultural diffusion. Some of these new, “old” learnings, which go way back yet seemed new in the 60s, spread. Ideas found in Eastern philosophies were introduced in the 1960s and spread widely in the 1970s.


Then in the 1980s, it continued spreading quietly, but at the same time, there was a tremendous backlash against it. The twelve years of Reagan and Bush presented much opposition. They were very, very opposed to many of the ideas. Of course, a lot of democrats were also opposed to the ideas of the 60s. It’s interesting, Reagan was elected to be governor of California on the basis of his promise to clobber the University of California. That was his primary platform. And he did it. He held back the free-speech movement. The Reagan administration sent helicopters to drop tear gas not only on the university but all over Berkley. I was over there during the People’s Park uprising and I was gassed-we were all gassed. All the Look people were trapped right in the middle of the campus. We were the only ones there on The Terrace who were watching this battle unfold beneath us. It was very bizarre. But there was that kind of backlash. So the movement entered into national politics in the 80s.


Now, during the 90s I think we are kind of teetering on the brink. We can go forwards or backwards, but I feel necessity will force us to realize that the old ways are simply not working. That repressiveness is not the answer. On the other hand, total license is not the answer either. Total freedom to do anything, the freedom to buy assualt weapons or do anything one wants, doesn’t work. There has to be some kind of long-term, disciplined practice. There has to be this understanding that that’s the way things work. I think there are quite a few hints that’s now happening.


DiCarlo: Do you think the 60s represented a kind of a “dress rehearsal” for the true transformation taking place in the 90s?


Leonard: The 60s certainly put the agenda for transformation up there. Now we’ve got to do it. There is so much more transformative activity going on now than in the 60s. Everybody thinks the 60s was radical. What was considered radical back then is kindergarten stuff compared to what’s going on now.


DiCarlo: What are some of the more hopeful signs that you see that we will move forward?


Leonard: A lot of things…. For example, never before in human history has so much of the great wisdom teaching of all ages and all cultures been so available throughout the world. It really is a global village. You can go to the corner drugstore and buy the Tibetan Book of The Dead. The easy availability is something new. Even a thinker as wise as Hagel did not have as much access to Oriental thought as an average college student does today. And of course a lot of information is being spread throughout the world via the satellites, through the communications network-the bad as well as the good. And that is something new. Very revolutionary. It contributed towards the downfall of communism. Havel said rock-and-roll caused the Berlin Wall to go down. That was his quote.


Another significant development is all the understanding we’re getting now on human evolution. You see new headlines constantly about the new male Lucy, the early ancestor of our species, for example, and the understanding of the power of the evolutionary process. One of the hallmarks of the project that Mike and I are working on, is the idea that evolution has not ended. The Future of The Body is about the next step. We are still evolving and I think things are really moving.


We have such a rich legacy of positive accomplishments. Just consider the Eskimo, Aruba tribesman, East Indian, Japanese Samurai, Christian Desert Fathers, the shaman, the Penitenti, Victorian Novelists, 20th century scientists…consider all the different kinds of governments, governance and philosophies that we have had. Embedded in this flamboyant richness, we’ve always had hints of further evolution. But now, all this diversity is becoming accessible everywhere on the earth. No one living before the mid-20th century-even the privileged king or monarch or greatest scientist of the time-has had as much access as we do today to the descriptions of metanormal capacities in people. Never before was there a medical science that could precisely measure the physiological changes produced by transformative practice. At no other time have so many people practiced so many different disciplines for growth and transcendence.


In public meeting places you find people practicing Sufi exercises that were once reserved for initiates. This stuff is really happening. Shamanic practices of Stone Age people are offered at workshops. It’s really spreading, more now than ever before. There’s a magazine called “Common Ground” published in the San Francisco area that has advertisements for literally hundreds of these activities. It is incredible. In the 60s this was simply not available. We have much, much more of this paradigm-busting lore now than we had back then. It’s not even close-it’s a thousand times more than what we had in the 60s.


Psychoneuroimmunology has had a powerful influence in the medical profession and is showing that emotions and feelings influence every aspect of bodily functioning. Ideas of the mind-body connection grace the covers of the news magazines now…The Bill Moyers Special, “Healing and the Mind” has had a very powerful influence on a relatively large audience. Not like Roseanne of course, but it doesn’t take all the people to make changes. It takes some of the people who are controlling the instruments of power, like those in the media.


A lot of experiments are going on, even though mainstream science is very loathe to admit it, which demonstrate that the minds of individuals can influence living tissue at a distance. They can influence bacteria, plants and other human beings. And these have been demonstrated in good, rigorous experiments, where the protocols and the procedures are much more closely monitored than they would be in a normal scientific experiment, where people are not so suspicious.


The anthropologists and sociologists have made so much progress too, in showing how our facial expressions, the way we walk, the way we move, how these things are influenced by culture. And how we can break out of these cultural traps.


Such martial arts as aikido, which I think is transformative, is now spreading throughout the world. It is a very transformative martial art that is based upon love and harmony. And that’s a very radical idea.


DiCarlo: Qi Gong also..


Leonard: Qi Gong and T’ai Chi continues to spread.


Very quietly the shift is occurring.


Also, the attitude of the media towards things such as Esalen has greatly shifted since the 1960s. In the very beginning before they knew what was happening, there were some wonderful articles about Esalen. Then by the 70s everybody who wrote about Esalen would talk about “touchy-feely” things while sticking their tongues in their cheeks. There was so much sticking of tongues in the cheeks that on Madison Avenue they had to develop a special operation to plug up the holes. But now, I have a whole press kit of articles that were written in 1987 about Esalen and every one of them is favorable. Part of the favorable response was simply a celebration of survival. Esalen endured and that’s pretty good. Nobody expected that. And when it hit its 30th birthday in 1992, there were even more favorable articles. It’s almost as if it’s now in the mainstream, an edge of the establishment. Recently Vogue and the New York Times all had very nice articles about Esalen. Today, Esalen is packed-you can’t even get in. So very, very quietly these “new/old” ideas are integrating into the very fabric of our society. It’s about something that appears to be almost essential to humanity. Without vision, without the understanding that there is the realm of the spirit that can give us guidance, that can give us meaning to life, I don’t think we can do anything. Life that is just consuming is totally an empty life. You can never get enough of what you really don’t want.


DiCarlo: Speaking of this realm of the spirit-Do you think there are beings that exist on different levels of reality that somehow guide the unfoldment of human potential?


Leonard: Well, I don’t think there is any question. What an impoverished universe it would be if what we see with our senses, and what we can pick up with our instruments of science represented all that there is in existence. Before the understanding of radio waves anybody who said you could hear a message from someone far away would have been labeled a kook. Are we arrogant enough to say that now our instruments have picked up all the emanations of life that exist? Of course there are more! Wherever you go, there is always more. And I don’t know what they are. I am not one of those who follows the idea of aliens and angels, but I would by very surprised, in fact, it’s unthinkable to me that our science and our senses have now picked up all the forms of life or energy that exist. There’s no question about it.


In my own L.E.T. work, Leonard Energy Training, we do exercises that are absolutely reliable, where average, untrained folks can wander around the room with eyes covered with cloth so they cannot see. When I clap my hands, the great majority of these people can point to the location of their partner who might be anywhere in the room or even outside the room. It takes a little induction to get people ready for this. One half hour-that’s all. But this is now routine. This is not special. This is not extraordinary. This is routine. We call this, “The Synchronization Process”.. I describe it briefly in the back of my book, The Silent Pulse.


So obviously, there is some kind of energy there that is not in the electromagnetic spectrum. We don’t want to be electro-magnetic chauvinists you know. There’s got to be more to the world than the electro-magnetic spectrum.


But there’s no question, there are other beings. There have got to be.


DiCarlo: Do you think scientists who are attempting to map and measure these other dimensions of “subtle” energies are heading in the right direction?


Leonard: Yes. Many years ago, myself and my ex-wife went to the University of California at Davis and were measured as we attempted to move our life energy from the right to the left hand. I still have the graphs. They were picking up electrical potentials off the back of each hand, and just by intention alone…we would say, “move energy right” and you would see the pulsations going up, up up, above the mid-line on the graph. Then we would say, “now bring the energy to the left” and you would see the line on the graph go down and over to the other side. Now, how is that done? I don’t know.


So I think, yes, let’s try to measure these things. You have to keep trying or else you’re not a real scientist. You’re not a scientist on the edge of discovery. I think it’s a wonderful idea.


DiCarlo: Could you elaborate on the integral practice for the development of human potential you have developed with Michael Murphy?


Leonard: Mike and I have written a book called The Life We Are Given. In a sense it is the follow upto Michael’s, The Future of The Body but it can stand totally alone. You might say that it is a book of instruction for the average person, which tells them what they can do to begin an integral transformative practice. Integral means, to integrate “mind, body, soul and heart.” Transformative mean that it’s based on positive change. Practice is a wonderful word, meaning something you do on a regular, disciplined basis. Not primarily for the goodies you get out of it, but primarily for the sake of doing it. A practice is the path you walk. You do it for its own sake. Paradoxically, the people who follow a practice for its own sake are the ones who get the most extraordinary results.


In part three of The Future of The Body Michael posits that the best way to achieve metanormal capacities, of perception, communication abilities, vitality, volition, etc. is through integral transformative practices. So for two years, throughout most of 1992 and 1993, we ran an experimental class. There were 33 people in the first group and 30 in the second group. We met for just two hours every Saturday but everybody had a number of commitments, things that they had to do every week. We kept very close statistics. We also had affirmations as to positive changes in their life and especially in their bodies. That’s something a lot of human potential workshops and experiments don’t do. They don’t keep close statistics which helps make things more understandable. We are offering a way for the average person to embark on this practice, just through reading this book and getting together with other folks.


DiCarlo: So this is a step-by-step methodology for individual transformation?


Leonard: Well, we have developed a step-by-step methodology for integral transformative practice. By doing that-and you can’t be sure-the odds are very good that you will get some positive transformation, because almost everybody, especially in the second cycle in 1993, got some very, very significant, positive changes. The amount of change is really quite spectacular. All sorts of wonderful changes in their body, some of which would have to be called metanormal and extraordinary.


DiCarlo: What would be some of the key elements of this practice?


Leonard: First of all, before we started these classes, I developed a less than 40 minute “kata”. Kata is just a convenient term in the martial arts which simply mean “form”. It’s a specific form where you go through a certain series of moves, always in the same sequence.


We asked that everyone in the course perform this kata at least 5 days a week. Some people did this seven days a week. It takes only 40 minutes because from the very beginning we wanted to make this a “householders path”. That is, a practice that can be engaged in by people who have jobs and a family. Not just people who live in a monastery or go on a retreat. So we wanted to do something that was feasible, and that was an important part of the experiment. These people all had jobs and families of sorts-they had a life other than this practice. But by doing the practice they got really remarkable results.


We asked all the participants to attend the class punctually and regularly. Also, we asked that everyone do at least three hours of aerobic exercise every week, in no increment less than 30 minutes. Everyone was also asked to be conscious of everything they ate, and a very low fat diet was recommended. We also recommended strength training but that was not absolutely required. We asked that everybody stay current in their emotional relations with all the people in the class, the teachers, and the people in their lives. We also did some emotional group work in the class, but we allowed people to do whatever they needed to do to handle that and report on it. Staying current in other words. Not letting things build up. Keeping the emotional information flowing to the appropriate people.


We also had affirmations. Everyone made four affirmations near the beginning of the class. These affirmations were written in the present tense, and went something like this, “I George Leonard, intend to see that the following circumstances have occurred by November 21, 1992.” Then, the rest is written in present tense, and for affirmation number one, we asked people to do things that are normal-not metanormal by any means. In other words, something that if you just did what you were supposed to do, you would achieve it and nobody would be surprised. It would be quite understandable through all the canons and concepts of present day science and medicine. For example, a person might affirm in writing, “My waist measures 32 inches” whereas it might measure 34 inches in the beginning.


All participants fill out a record of their affirmations, which is kept in a file. At the end, on November the 21st using this example, they would make note of their progress. If they have really watched their diet, and if they have done the aerobic exercises and perhaps the strength exercises, no one should be surprised that they have achieved this intended outcome.


The second affirmation for the first year was what we call, “exceptional”. Something that could still be explained by modern, mainstream science, but which would be an exception. Such as, “I measure 5 foot 6 inches” and your measurement right now is 5 foot 5 inches. Well, to grow an inch at age forty is kind of unusual isn’t it? I think most people can grow about a third of an inch or a half of an inch just by improving their posture. But to actually grow measurably a whole inch would be kind of exceptional.


We rated people on a scale of zero to ten to see how well they achieved their affirmations. We tried to make it as objective as possible with measurements. We didn’t restrict it to the objective because that would be too limiting, but we had people make it objective as much as possible. In other words, if a person were affirming an improvement in eyesight, we asked them to go to an eye doctor and have the eyes measured and have a record of it in the beginning and again, eleven months later. Incidentally, in that particular case we got remarkable results.


The third affirmation was the metanormal, something that could not be explained by traditional science and something that rarely happens to people. For example, a metanormal affirmation might be to grow two inches. And we got fascinating results. In fact, during the 1993 program, the success in achieving affirmation number three was 6.67 on a scale from zero to ten.


The fourth affirmation was the same for everybody, “My entire body is balanced, vital and healthy.” We wanted to cover this base because we didn’t want someone to achieve an unusual metanormal state at the expense of their health and balance. And that was one that we really excelled at with an 8.2 overall improvement in health on a zero to 10 scale.


Taking a look at all this gave us some ideas for some very practical applications. We cannot solve our health care crisis in a financially viable way. It is impossible to do it no matter what method we use, as long as we continue to use our present method of medical technology, which is sickness based and relies upon expensive drugs and expensive technology. The only way we can make it work is through a radical change in lifestyle. And if we can change the lifestyle of a group of ordinary Americans, improving their health by 8.2 on a scale of 0 to 10, we can save hundreds of billions of dollars in this country. So it’s very practical.


So we asked that everyone fulfill their affirmations. In other words, they continued to speak their affirmations in various ways. In practice we used focused surrender, which was one of our best methods and inductions for achieving these meta-normalities.


DiCarlo: Focused surrender? What’s that?


Leonard: While writing The Silent Pulse , I noticed there seem to be certain magical moments in life, which I call periods of perfect rhythm, where everything seems perfect. If you go one way that’s exactly the right way and you’ll find something marvelous there; if you go the other way that’s the right way, and so forth and so on. These moments of perfect rhythm generally come in a period where you have concentrated very hard on something. You are really focused. After this period of intense concentration, you surrender. You let go of that which you were focusing upon. Focused surrender is a combination of these two actions.


There’s a big debate going on right now: Is the petitioned form of prayer, where an individual requests something specific, like a cure from an illness, more effective than accepting prayer, thanksgiving prayer, like “Thy Will Be Done”. There has been research studying the effectiveness of various kinds of prayer on various kinds of organisms. The debate is still open. Some people come down on the side, “Thy Will Be Done” as the best way to go about it. In other words, surrender.


Now what I have done-and I did this way back in the 70s-is to devise a way where you really get both. A combination of the two. And it’s really at the point where you surrender that magical things might begin to happen. Extraordinary things. What I call this is a “mental-material interface”. In Integral Transformation Practice training we have an activity where we sound a gong. As long as the participant can hear the gong, they are to focus with all their power on making whatever state they want to achieve absolutely real in their consciousness. This is real in the present moment in this universe, because your consciousness is a part of this universe. If you want to experience yourself as being an inch taller, you see yourself as an inch taller. That exists in your consciousness and it’s real. Take the example of the wiring diagram of a little radio. The radio itself is real. No one would dispute that since it is concrete and exists in three dimensions. Of course, if you drop it and step on it, it won’t work anymore. It’s broken. There’s also a wiring diagram. That’s real too, it’s just on two dimensions primarily. Now, how about the diagram as it exists in the mind of the inventor, of the person who works on that radio. Is that real or not? My argument is that these represent three different forms of reality, but they are all equally real.


So next, the person is instructed to follow the tone of the gong down into the void itself, into the nothingness. When it reaches that void and nothingness from which all things arise-the creative void-they completely let go of whatever they are envisioning. The way we do it, you are lying on your back and you hold your left hand up over your abdomen as long as you can hear the sound. If you can no longer hear the sound, drop it. Say, “I give up.” What we have found-and we can’t prove this-is that at the moment of surrender, the mental-material interface somehow clicks in. In other words, what was real in the mental realm, to some small extent becomes real in the material realm. Of all the methods we have tried, focused-surrender has turned out to be our most effective induction.


The great warrior works to achieve control, then acts with abandon. In aikido, I have worked and worked and worked on certain techniques, but when I’m being attacked, if I think about the techniques, I’ve had it. You have got to let go totally. Just let it happen. Achieve control, then act with abandon. Many great sports achievements, and many great achievements in the world, I think, result from the combination of the two.


DiCarlo: I like that because then you get a blend between personal will and perhaps Higher Will. There’s no conflict, just a creative dance between the individual and the universe.


Leonard: Boy, you’ve got it exactly. It’s not one or the other. The idea of focused surrender in which the mental and material can touch, individual will finally letting go to grace. As Mike said in his book, “The winds of grace are always blowing, you just have to raise your sails.”


DiCarlo: What sort of metanormal capabilities have manifested for some of the people?


Leonard: There’s one woman in her mid-40s whose grandfather on her mother’s side went practically blind from cataracts. This was before the condition could be treated through surgery, and this man could barely see. Her mother had the cataract operation in her 40s. This woman has three older sisters, and each of them had the cataract operation while they were in their 40s. It was an absolutely genetic condition. When this woman in the class had achieved the age of 42, she developed cataracts, which was noted in her yearly examination and she assumed she too would have the operation since one of the cataracts was near the middle of the cornea.


So she made an affirmation in the 1992 class that her eyes were free of cataracts. Unfortunately, when she went in for the first examination, she told the eye doctor. He scoffed at the idea. He said, “well, you can change some things, but cataracts you can never change.” Still, she was a good student and did that work and every time she did the kata she would take the palms of her hand and place them three or four inches from each eye, kind of stroking the eyes with the energy in the palms of each hand, saying, “My vision is clear. My eyes are free of cataracts.”


When time at the end of the 92 cycle came, this woman just couldn’t face going in for her eye exam because the doctor had been so certain the condition could not be healed without surgery. If you’ve ever wondered why people don’t achieve their potential, this is one example. The cultural pressure of the current paradigm is extremely powerful and is enunciated in so many different ways by the experts and the acknowledged authorities in each field.


Although the woman had given up on it , she continued doing the affirmation every time she did the kata, which was five times a week. Near the end of the second year of the program, she needed some prescription sunglasses and her old prescription was out of date. She went to the same hospital as before and after she had the exam she waited for the usual cataract lecture. The doctor said, “Do you have any inherited eye problems?” She responded, “Don’t you know? How about my cataracts?” “What cataracts?,” said the doctor. They were gone.


DiCarlo: That’s an incredible example of realized human potential. I’m wondering, how does this potential, which is inherently in us all, get blocked? You’ve already mentioned cultural pressures…


Leonard: Let me give you some examples…. You know how as schoolchildren, we all worried that we didn’t have enough ability. We weren’t sure that we were going to do well enough on the achievement tests. Well, I really believe that the biggest threat to the establishment is not underachieving, but rather it’s the threat of overachieving.


When I was covering education back in the 1960s, I was going around the country doing an article on programmed education. In fact, it was that same story , “Revolution in Education” that gave me the idea for the human potential story. It was in Roanoke, Virginia, where I had heard about this student at a local junior high school who had taken a simple programmed course on solid geometry home for a long weekend. He finished one semester’s worth of work over that period, Friday until Monday. Now do you think the school system would cheer about that?


DiCarlo: You would think they would marvel at the accomplishment..


Leonard: No, they thought, “what the hell do we do with this guy?” What do you do with the kids who come into first grade reading very fluently? The system is set-up to keep everybody in lock-step. Those who are not in lock-step are a threat to the system.


I think that humans natural tendency is to learn. We are learning animals. We are put here on this planet to learn. We are genetically endowed to learn a great deal over a lifetime rather than having to wait through the mechanisms of evolution, of mutation and selection and so forth. Because of this, changes can be made during one lifetime. But unfortunately, there is actually very little positive reinforcement, and much adversive conditioning which is opposed to people achieving their full potential.


DiCarlo: Would you say that it’s a control issue?


Leonard: Control?


DiCarlo: In so far as certain people in society wanting to control us in certain ways…


Leonard: I don’t think it’s any conscious control. In my book, The Transformation I offer the whole idea of the human individual as being a component of society as an example of one of the inventions of civilization. The first pyramid building gangs you might say. We specialize and standardize components so they are reliable and predictable. A true learner is none of those things. A learner is eternally surprising. Unpredictable. Not necessarily reliable to do the same job the same way every time. So the entire system works against the full development of human potential. The system works against learning. Our present school system actually set-up to stop the human organism from learning in a really radical and deep way.


To learn is to change. Education is a process which changes the learner. How much are we willing for our students to change in school? You know, they see, “Two plus two,” and before they have learned elementary addition they will just look at it with a blank expression on their face. After being taught they can say, “four.” And that is a change. So that’s definitely a learning. Our children are learning certain amounts of symbolic manipulation and the memorization of a bit of the common cultural material, but in learning to be a learner, and learning to create, in learning to love, in learning to feel deeply, there is a tremendous constraint against learning, if learning is any kind of significant change. And if learning is not any kind of significant change, then what the hell is it? In other words, if you don’t change after a learning experience, if you are not different from when the learning experience started, you have not learned much. Learning is not truly respected. Education as it is now constituted really works against learning in the deepest sense. You don’t want people to change deeply because it would be very worrisome to the system.


I have often thought about this: Let’s say that learning is done in segments. I am not sure that’s even the right way to do it, but if learning is done in segments in school, at the end of each segment, the teacher should not be necessary. In other words, the teacher should fade from prominence. Maybe one of the jobs of a teacher is to set the learners on a course of learning, and then gradually fade himself or herself, so that the last day, the students wouldn’t even notice the teacher there.


DiCarlo: That would be a switch..


We need to cultivate a real respect for learning. You know, people’s thought of the human potential movement does not normally include calculus. I think it does include calculus. Mike and I both feel that way. Another requirement we had in our Integral Transformative Practice Club (ITP), was that everybody would agree to read assignments and write essays. That doesn’t sound very New Age does it?


DiCarlo: Not at all…


Leonard: But that’s integral transformative practice-it’s across the board. We feel that to neglect any of those four aspects of being human-mind, body, heart or soul-is a big mistake. People will do things if they know why they are doing them. If they have some kind of vision as to why they are doing them. We need vision. Every viable culture and every successful individual needs at least two guardian angels-vision and practice. Both of those have been totally lost. They have become endangered species in the culture of the freeway and shopping mall.


Vision is given away to obsession with short term goals; practice is given away to the quick fix. “The One Minute Manager”, “Total Fitness in One Week”. Almost all “how-to” books; New Age books are mostly quick-fix books. And you don’t learn anything by the quick fix. It takes long-term regular practice.


There’s an old Eastern idea that “where there is no practice, nations fall into ruin.” I think we have to get the idea of long-term, regular practice for everybody, rather than “10 Easy Lessons” or “Fast, Temporary Relief”-all the slogans you hear in this culture.


Just take a look at the areas in which we have our biggest problems: the economy; health care; politics; pharmacology; crime; and environment, the most important one of all. Look at each of these. The factor that is common to each problem involves long term versus short-term. In all of those, we tend to do what seems best on the short term, but what we are really doing is losing the long term. Almost always, the short term is inimical to the long term. Sometimes you have to do both, but we’ve almost totally neglected the long term. So I think that factor, long term versus short term is something people need to take a look at.


When you adopt a practice, you’re in it for the long haul. You work, and work and work on a thing. You diligently keep practicing the same thing over and over again. You are not getting anywhere- or so you think. But you are getting somewhere. It doesn’t show itself. Then finally when it clicks in, you have this little spurt of apparent progress. But where did the learning take place? It took place on the plateau.


Just think about all those years people worked against the whole communist system. Then in a period of a few weeks, the Berlin wall goes down. Then a few months afterwards most of the eastern satellites had given up communism. Some said, “My God, change occurred very fast.” But in reality, that change was occurring over the last 20 or 30 years. The change occurred because of long time learning. And the learning occurs on the plateau. So if I have any message, I want to preach the plateau…you have to preach the plateau to young people. Just hang in there.





Excerpted from the book Towards A New World View: Conversations At The Leading Edge with Russell E. DiCarlo. The 377-page book features new and inspiring interviews with 27 paradigm pioneers in the fields of medicine, psychology, economics, business, religion, science, education and human potential. Featuring: Willis Harman, Matthew Fox, Joan Boysenko, George Leonard, Gary Zukav, Robert Monroe, Hazel Henderson, Fred Alan Wolf, Peter Senge, Jacquelyn Small, Elmer Green, Larry Dossey, Carolyn Myss, Stan Grof, Rich Tarnas, Marilyn Ferguson, Marsha Sinetar, Dr. Raymond Moody, Stephen Covey and Peter Russell.


Russell E. DiCarlo is a medical writer, author, lecturer and workshop leader who’s focus is on personal transformation, consciousness research and the fields of energy and anti-aging medicine. His forthcoming book is entitled “The Definitive Guide To Anti-Aging Medicine” (1998, Future Medicine Publishing). DiCarlo resides in Erie, Pennsylvania.

Copyright 1996. Epic Publishing. All Rights Reserved.

?O?? ?s^s^s^s^s^s^s^s ®G?«

]]>
23582
Special Populations and Exercise: A New Era In Fitness https://healthy.net/2018/12/06/special-populations-and-exercise-a-new-era-in-fitness-2/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=special-populations-and-exercise-a-new-era-in-fitness-2 Thu, 06 Dec 2018 13:28:00 +0000 https://healthy.net/2000/12/06/special-populations-and-exercise-a-new-era-in-fitness-2/ Introduction

There is an old adage that active people seek active lifestyles, and that Darwin’s theory of natural selection applies to exercise. It has always been hard to truly tell if exercise is associated with improved health, or whether healthy people are naturally drawn to more active tasks. For those who are still not convinced about the benefits of exercise as part of a healthier lifestyle, it has been a tough argument to refute.

Back in the mid 1980’s evidence started to mount that if people engaged in exercise over periods of time, they may reduce their chances of acquiring certain types of diseases, such as heart disease, and other cardiovascular disorders. Research also pointed out that regular exercise may reduce premature mortality, thus assisting persons in living longer through maintaining a healthy lifestyle. These results were independent of their gender, places where they lived, their body weight, and other types of medical conditions, such as blood pressure status, and family history of a particular disease.

The concept of exercise in the past ten years has moved into a new realm – that of looking at the the effects of exercise on special populations. Special populations groups are persons with diseases, and other metabolic conditions that are usually under the care of physicians or other health care personnel.

Exercise and Special Populations – Pregnancy

One of the first special population groups to be studied directly under exercise conditions were pregnant women. For many years previously, obstetricians felt that exercise may harm the developing baby and cause unnecessary problems during pregnancy and delivery. This was in the absence of any concrete scientific information.

Over the past 15 years there have been many research reports on the effects of exercise on pregnant women, from their response to different exercise programs, to their birth outcomes. The results have been impressive, in that most women seem to fair better physically when performing regular moderate exercise regimens than those who remain sedentary over the course of their pregnancies. Although there is still a lag between information presented in journals and articles, and what many physicians recommend, the consensus today is that an active lifestyle with this group may be better for both mom and baby.

Current reports highlight the need for pregnant women to perform low-impact aerobic exercise that will help with metabolism after the second trimester, and not injure joints that are being softened up in the third trimester for delivery. Walking 1-2 times per day after meals seems to help burn excess energy, and aerobic exercises such as the UBE (Upper Body Ergometer), and Aqua-JoggingTM in a pool with a special buoyancy vest are two very good ways to stay in shape without excess stress to joints. They can be performed using basic fitness guidelines of 20-30 minutes, 3-4 days per week, keeping the heart rate in the training zone. Your physician should be kept abreast of your fitness program, and any unusual situations should be discussed with him/her.

Exercise and Seniors

Another special population group receiving attention in the medical literature and lay person press is the senior age group (55 years and over). For most of this century we were told that gaining weight, losing strength, developing disease, and losing energy were simply a part of the natural aging process. With the growing number of studies looking at exercise and life span, body fat loss, increasing strength, and reducing the incidence of certain diseases, through regular exercise over the years, it is becoming clear that inactivity – not aging per se, is the culprit in most, if not all, types of chronic diseases.

The senior population has had a boost for performing fitness routines with a report from Tufts University in Boston showing increases in strength in persons over 80 years old. Strength changes were demonstrated in subjects over a training program, with increases totaling over 170%. Even after a period of detraining, subjects still tested higher in strength scores than before they entered the program.

These results clearly show the need for incorporating moderate exercise programming at any age. The beneficial effects are being seen in groups once thought to have no business being in the workout environment.

Two areas of most concern to seniors are both bone and muscle weakness – the former with the concept of osteoporosis, and the latter with a decline in muscle strength and endurance over time. Again, walking has been shown to have an impact on cardiovascular fitness, and the use of aerobic machines may provide an improvement in workload over time without the impact on joints. Thera-Bandsª or rubber tubing are helpful with a beginning resistance exercise training program, and signing up with an exercise class, or having an instructor consult individually is helpful in getting a program started. Common sense, moderation, and proper exercise progression provide the intensity stimulus in the first month or so of exercise training.

Populations at risk for disease

For pregnant women and seniors, the benefits of regular exercise have been highlighted both in research and health periodicals. The question still remains if these particular populations are any more susceptible to disease because of their status. So, if we as our original question – does exercise help enhance health levels, or do they naturally select exercise to start out with?

The study of medical populations may give us a clue as to how exercise may be beneficial at improving health, independent of other variables that may contribute to health in the first place (such as genetics, dietary factors, where you live, etc.).

Diabetes affects over 20 million Americans, with over 5,000 new cases of diabetes being diagnosed every week. For over 70 years exercise has been touted as being part of the trilogy of treatment for persons with diabetes (along with a proper diet, and regular insulin routine). However, exercise has received little practical impetus from the health community, mainly because no one was sure what type of exercise, or how much was needed to actually impact diabetes care. Inactivity is seen as one of the major risk factors for development of diabetes over time, as is increased the likelihood of developing glucose intolerance, and insulin resistance. These factors are the reasons why many older adults develop diabetes later in life.

With the publication of three relevant research studies in 1991 and 1992, the question of exercise and its benefits for diabetes has been answered to a greater degree.

Two years ago, researchers from The University of California looked at alumni records from former university students to see who had been exercising regularly since their graduation from college (as far back at 1927). University records keep tabs on all students as to job occupation, health status, medical visits, leisure time activity, etc. Data was collected for many years, and when it was analyzed, it was found at alumni who exercised frequently (3 or more times per week), had less incidence for developing adult onset diabetes. Their risk for developing diabetes was almost half that of persons who did not exercise at all. This finding was independent of their family history of diabetes, and other physical factors, such as body weight and blood pressure status.

Within that same year another study was published in the British medical journal, the Lancet, with essentially the same results as the University of California study, only this time in an entirely different group of people, using the same type of research methods. This ongoing investigation is called the Nurse’s Health Study – which looks at health objectives in a sample of the nation’s nurses, was the data base. Information was collected from this group over years to assess health status in these women. After comparing those who exercised regularly versus their sedentary counterparts, the same type of results appeared. Those who exercised had almost a 33 percent less incidence of acquiring diabetes over time, independent of other factors.

Almost a year after the first publication, the Physician’s Health Study looked at exercising doctors and compared them with non-exercising counterparts. Again, those physicians who exercised at least 2 to 4 days per week had less incidence for diabetes development by about 30%, and those who exercised 5 or more days per week reduced their risk by 40%.

These series of investigations lend clear evidence to the concept of a protective effect of regular exercise in different population groups who may be at risk for developing disease over the course of their lifetimes. As scientists follow other groups of persons over years, we will learn more about the effects of exercise on mortality statistics, medical care, and enhanced quality of life for individuals.

Persons with diabetes should be concerned with keeping blood sugar levels at normal ranges throughout the day. They must avoid low blood sugar (hypoglycemia) due to prolonged exercise, as well. This balance is achieved through self blood sugar monitoring – using a small reflectance meter and sample of blood from a finger stick to keep track of sugar levels in the bloodstream. Self blood sugar monitoring is the cornerstone of good diabetes control, and may help avoid long term complications of the disease, such as blindness, gangrene, and heart disease.

Most exercises can be performed with diabetic persons, as long as self monitoring is part of their program. By knowing current sugar levels, they can safely plan the intensity and duration of their exercise. If they have had diabetes for longer than 10 years, lower impact exercises may be beneficial to guard against damaging feet, which may have some neuropathy (nerve damage). Consulting with personal physicians, and exercise specialists will produce individual exercises programs for improved health.

Medical populations

Exercise with medical patients started with cardiac rehabilitation. Patients were weaned into low intensity exercise programs using aerobic machines, later walking programs, and at the present, supervised exercise consisting of aerobics, weight training, and stretching programs. Their exercise options have grown as to what types of programs they can perform, and how it may effect their risk for cardiac abnormalities later in life. The goal for cardiac rehab programs to date is to reduce the incidence of recurrent heart problems in patients who have undergone bypass surgery, or had previous heart attacks.

For persons at risk, exercise may have an impact on reducing the occurrence, or severity of disease. What about persons who are already afflicted with a disease, such as high blood pressure?

One in four American has hypertension, and exercise has been studied as to its effects on blood pressure for over 25 years. Most persons who exercise regularly know that training raises blood pressure during the performance of the exercise itself. Many health professionals have been reluctant to tell their patients to exercise because of this fact.

However, exercise training over time reduces blood pressure levels. The key is finding the right type of exercise program that will not raise blood pressure much during exercise, and have beneficial long-term effects.

It has been found that moderate aerobic training (walking, aerobic machines, swimming, etc.) have little effect on blood pressure levels, if they are performed at a certain heart rate range. Regular exercise is best at keeping blood pressure levels in check. Sporadic training routines have little effect in the long run, and persons may not get into their exercising “groove” in terms of figuring out their heart rate, and their exercise intensity.

Dr. Deepak Chopra, the author of “Quantum Healing”, has added much information as to the effects of changing lifestyle and its effect on cancer patients. Those who perform meditation, regular exercise, and dietary interventions have had a better recovery from their cancer-related therapies. Exercise plays an important part of cancer recovery by strengthening weak muscles, adding more functional capacity in persons who have little energy for daily work activities, and boosting self-esteem though successful performance of tasks, and achieving goals. Moderate walking and water exercise programs have been successful with this group. The use of rubber tubing substitutes for dumb bells in terms of muscle strengthening. In the future exercise may be a part of every cancer patient’s recovery package.

One of the most interesting areas of exercise and medical populations is the effect exercise has on blood lipids. As heart disease is the worst chronic disease afflicting Americans, anything that can reduce cholesterol and other blood fats in the diet, and by other means is regarded highly.

It seems that aerobic exercise (and to some extent, strength training), has an effect on lowering total cholesterol with exercise. It raises the protective cholesterol (HDL), and reduces the atherosclerotic-producing cholesterol (LDL), along with cholesterol sub-fractions which may have an effect on health status. Judging by its effects on hyperlipidemia (high fat levels in the blood), patients with this disorder may use exercise as a type of medicine, and the right “prescription” may help reduce their blood fat levels, reducing their chance of suffering a cholesterol-related heart problem.

Arthritis patients have had to deal with pain their joints with every movement. So why should they exercise – as exercise makes joints move in lots of directions, and sometimes with a heavier load than just getting around? Exercise has been shown with this group to have beneficial effects of lessening the pain and inflammation of chronic rheumatoid arthritis. Programs such as PACE (People with Arthritis Can Exercise) have opened doors for persons and given them options as to what types of exercises they can perform, and the effects of exercise over prolonged periods of time.

Exercise has been shown to have beneficial effects in patients with Cystic Fibrosis, Post-Polio Syndrome, Raynaud’s Syndrome, End-Stage Renal Disease, Pulmonary Disease, and Peripheral Vascular Disease. Exercise is also being studied as to its beneficial effects on newer diseases such as HIV/AIDS, and Chronic Fatigue Syndrome. The American College of Sports Medicine has set guidelines for exercise professionals on dealing with these types of patients during exercise situations. With a joint effort by the health care community, patients who would have never thought of using exercise as part of their medical treatment may be working with their exercise specialist in addition to their doctor, nurse, dietitian, or physical therapist.

A Basic Medical Exercise Program

What constitutes a medical exercise program? Does an adult onset diabetic person have a different exercise program than an arthritic patient? As exercise programming is as individual as people, no two should have the exact type of program. Whether patients are working out in a supervised exercise setting, or participating in an aerobic exercise class, there are a few types of guidelines that are universal, and may help structure individual exercise.

  1. Proper monitoring before exercise. Whether is is blood sugar monitoring, using a blood pressure cuff, taking a temperature reading, or stepping on the scale, performing a physical reading pre-exercise is important to see how hard and long you may be able to perform.
  2. Proper warm-up. In a class full of students, or on your own, getting the muscles prepared for exercise is as easy as doing some light aerobic movements, and large-muscle stretching activities to get ready for the body of the exercise.
  3. New goals and objectives. The goals for therapeutic exercises are – pain free movement, improved functional ability, learning new body movements, and perfecting technique on whatever type of exercise you are performing. If people thought about improving their technique in the weight room, or the aerobic dance floor, they would decrease their risks of ever having an injury – as the competitive nature of exercise takes a back seat to self-improvement and self-awareness. It has been said that Socrates learned to dance at 70 years of age because he felt that a part of himself needed improvement. Therapeutic exercise is half education, and half workout. Teaching patients new physical skills, and offering them instruction on how to deal with new movement is part of the objectives. It differs from mainstream exercise programs where individuals need much less guidance. The rewards are not just improvements in physical condition, but new tools to work with on their own (at home), and hopefully a new found sense of self acceptance and confidence to become healthier, and more self reliant.
  4. Proper warm-down. In sports, warm down may mean a few stretches before going home. The importance of proper warm down in therapeutic situations cannot be overlooked. It is time for breathing (slow, proper belly breathing), it is a time for reflection and relaxation, and getting yourself “centered”, and it is a time to let the muscles flush out the extra work they have been asked to perform, and be able to function properly the next day without undue soreness. For patients who have been in stressful healing situations, the warm down serves as their focus to reduce pain, increase mental strength, and increase their own healing abilities.

There is no one type of exercise routine for medical situations, so no sample program is listed. A bit of reading and investigating by the individual will help them gain access to qualified professionals to help them start on their own program.

Tomorrow’s Exercise

Exercise in medicine, despite all of the research expounding its benefits, is still in its infancy. There are scattered programs around the country that provide exercise therapy for medical patients. Many health professionals are hesitant to refer patients to health clubs, as most employees are not well versed in medical aspects of disease. For those with extensive exercise physiology backgrounds, setting up private practice is also difficult, as the profession is not a licensed entity.

None the less, the future of exercise with medical populations seems to gaining momentum. More types of out-patient programs are cropping up, and some hospitals have adopted a rehabilitative format, performing therapy services in addition to acute patient care.

We would hope that it is part of a change in the system that now pays an enormous amount of money for medical procedures, to one which will help pay costs for “preventive health care”, which would include diet and exercise as the main components. Time will tell as to how the current political administration will handle today’s health care issues. If individuals are aware of the benefits of exercise therapy for special population needs, perhaps they will seek out exercise instruction in their community, and make a change in the system by themselves.

About the author:

Eric P. Durak received his Master’s degree in Exercise Physiology from the University of Michigan in 1986. His research and clinical interests include exercise applications for special populations groups, such as diabetes (IDDM, NIDDM, GDM), pregnancy, and metabolic disorders. He has published scientific articles in: The American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Diabetes Care, Sports Training, Medicine, Rehabilitation, and The Somatics Journal. He is the author of “Exercise and Diabetes – a Guidebook for Health Professionals, published through Medical Health and Fitness, based in Santa Barbara, CA.

]]>
21631
It Stands To Reason Sitting Less Can Improve Health, Extend Life https://healthy.net/2013/03/29/it-stands-to-reason-sitting-less-can-improve-health-extend-life/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=it-stands-to-reason-sitting-less-can-improve-health-extend-life Fri, 29 Mar 2013 20:09:01 +0000 https://healthy.net/2013/03/29/it-stands-to-reason-sitting-less-can-improve-health-extend-life/ There appears to be one common theme in today’s hustle and bustle society – people are too busy to squeeze much physical activity into their daily routines. However, millions of Americans have all the time in the world, it seems, to sit.


Ongoing research is linking high amounts of sedentary time – prolonged sitting – to increased incidence of cancer, heart disease, obesity, diabetes and early death. Excessive sitting may also be responsible for low back pain, according to researchers here who also say there is a way to burn more calories and increase one’s lifespan by tweaking one small thing – sitting less and standing more.



According to Dr. Anup Kanodia, a family medicine physician and researcher from the Center for Personalized Health Care at The Ohio State University’s Wexner Medical Center, lipoprotein lipase, an enzyme which is responsible for converting low-density lipoprotein (LDL), or bad cholesterol, into high-density lipoprotein (HDL), or good cholesterol, decreases 95 percent when you sit too long. This, in turn, could be one factor of excessive sitting which increases risk of heart attack by 30 percent.



“In a little over 150 years, we have gone from a society that stood or walked for 90 percent of the waking day to one that sits for 60 percent. Most people are coming into work and leaving sicker,” adds Kanodia, also from the Center for Integrative Medicine at Ohio State’s Wexner Medical Center.



Ohio State’s Wexner Medical Center is spearheading a “mobile campaign” which encourages university faculty, staff and students to participate in improving their overall quality of health and includes incorporating standing as much as possible. The campaign has been embraced and adopted by leaders who are setting a non-sitting example, starting at the very top with Dr. Steven G. Gabbe, CEO of the Medical Center. Gabbe uses an elevated table to complete paperwork and other tasks on a daily basis. In addition, many employees organize and facilitate standing meetings.



This allows for open dialogue among attendees about the health consequences of excessive sitting, and conductors can also empower those present to stand as well, if they wish. Another way Ohio State employees and students are proving their commitment to standing is by holding walking meetings outside when appropriate. They use modern technology to take notes and record minutes. Also, tools and equipment that encourage standing, such as podiums and treadmill desks, are being shared in conference rooms and offices.



“When you’re standing or moving around, your muscles contract. They’re moving around and insulin helps the body in terms of moving sugar from the blood into different cells. But, when you’re sitting, none of that happens. So, if you’re on a conference call or participating in a webinar, do yourself a favor and stand up,” encourages Kanodia, discussing the benefits to standing.



The following are a few additional easy tips for standing to consider throughout the day:


  • Move from a sitting position to standing more often. When possible, get up and take a five-minute walk every hour.
  • Use a timer or computer program that can provide cues or prompts at designated intervals as reminders to get up and move.
  • Be aware of habits outside of the workplace or classroom and try to minimize time spent sitting as much as possible.

The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center is part of a university-wide movement which promotes prevention and treatment, health and the transformation of healthcare delivery globally through research and innovation, evidence-based practices and community engagement.



Provided by Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center on 7/3/2012

]]>
21469
Brain Health, Exercise and BDNF https://healthy.net/2011/12/07/brain-health-exercise-and-bdnf/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=brain-health-exercise-and-bdnf Wed, 07 Dec 2011 22:33:01 +0000 https://healthy.net/2011/12/07/brain-health-exercise-and-bdnf/ We got it! It’s BDNF! Brain derived neurotrophic factor. That’s the key to preserving memory and brain health as we age. It’s a name we all need to become familiar with as I’m certain new research will blossom from this paper. This is the link with exercise and cognitive decline. Dr. Griffin et al from Trinity College in Dublin took a group of young exercising men and measured their BDNF levels in comparison to their ability to remember faces on both an acute and a chronic level of fitness training. What they found was that exercise raises their levels of BDNF, and that correlates with their ability to remember complex face recognition patterns.


BDNF is a protein that stimulates your brain to put out new neurons and for those connections with other neurons to stick. It is critical to learning. Many of our neurons are fixed at birth and don’t change much over our life times. Our first couple of years have massive amounts of remodeling and making connections between our neurons with maturation continuing up into our twenties. But the concept of neuroplasticity and the ability of the brain to grow new pathways is also emerging and we are beginning to realize that the brain is not a fixed, static entity that gradually loses it’s ability to grow. At any time in life we can grow new brain cells. It is particularly active in the hippocampus, cortex and basal forebrain where we have the most important parts for neural memory and higher thinking type functions.



The New York Times article also references a study in older pilots who were asked to practice in a flight simulator repeatedly over several years. Their ability to function in the complex world of flying an airplane was shown to decline with age. More interesting was that those pilots with markers for low BDNF declined the most in their ability. This suggests that BDNF is particularly important to maintaining memory and cognitive function.



You can’t take BDNF as a pill. It is a complex, large protein. But at any age in life you can stimulate it to be more present. It’s hard to take humans brains out and examine them, but in rat models of aging, the NYT article references several studies in which aging rats were allowed to exercise and then had their brains looked at for BDNF content. Sure enough, exercise stimulated BDNF and its precursor molecules within a week. And the older exercising rats performed almost as well as younger rats on memory tests.


WWW. What will work for me.<.B> Now that winter is upon me, I need a little more motivation to get moving. I have to go somewhere to exercise because it’s not so easy to run outside. My BDNF might just be it. Very interesting concept. BDNF.



Reference: New York Times, Nov 30th, 2011, Physiological Behavior, Oct 24, 2011

]]>
6283
Integrative Medicine, Complementary Alternative Medicine and Health Round-up #49: November 2011 https://healthy.net/2011/11/24/integrative-medicine-complementary-alternative-medicine-and-health-round-up-49-november-2011/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=integrative-medicine-complementary-alternative-medicine-and-health-round-up-49-november-2011 Thu, 24 Nov 2011 18:03:03 +0000 https://healthy.net/2011/11/24/integrative-medicine-complementary-alternative-medicine-and-health-round-up-49-november-2011/ Summary: Integrative community dialogue on board certified integrative MDs and the direction of “integrative medicine” … Congressional Wellness Caucus established with bipartisan backing … Obama names Kahn and Ornish to Advisory Group for National Prevention Council … IHPC’s Partners for Health group expands … Integrative medicine not featured at TEDMED 2011, moves to the Beltway in 2012 … Knutson urges response to US Preventive Medicine Task Force … Dartmouth researcher Davis breaks down $$$ in CAM market … Bastyr reports $136-million of economic impact … CHP Group offers case statement for CAM integration … Steiner Leisure purchases Cortiva Group … Sabin on role of philanthropy in integrative medicine … Chesney in line to chair conventional academic consortium … Acupuncturist Beau Anderson gains faculty appointment at Albert Einstein … Taylor Walsh adds perspective on debate over whether alternative medicine killed Steve Jobs … IAYT’s John Kepner addresses the Group Health findings relative to “sham yoga” … Report on naturopathic profession’s Science & Policy Summit … Chiropractors push inclusion in loan repayment … New Hampshire Republicans cross party line to support mandate to cover naturopathic doctors … Acupuncture Without Borders in tough financial position … American Medical Student Association leader is a naturopathic medical student, SCNM’s Rebecca Snowden … Zunin’s Manakai O Malama, Hawai’i’s most significant integrative center, seeks additional integrative MD/DO … Christina Jackson named the 2011 Holistic Nurse of the Year … Rita Bettenburg takes position at CHP Group

Policy

Image

Taking lead on board certification

Expansive integrative community
dialogue on effort to create an MD specialty through an American Board
of Integrative Medicine

The September 2011 “strategic change in direction” by
leaders of the Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine to promote recognition of a
board-certified integrative medicine specialty prompted significant, sometimes fractious
dialogue in the integrative practice community. Some
perspectives on the proposed American Board of Integrative Medicine (ABIM) were
captured in Integrator Forum: 20 Voices on Weil/University of Arizona and the American Board of Integrative Medicine.
This diverse grouping of responses included MDs, DCs, NDs, AOM leaders and others,
including two anti-“Quackademic” bloggers. A second set of respondents
contributed after reading the dialogue in the first group. These are captured here:
Forum #2 on the American Board of Integrative Medicine: Quinn, Redwood, Gmeiner, Anderson and Manahan.
The Arizona’s Center’s change in direction is from promoting “integrative medicine” as the
right approach for every branch of medicine to advocating formation
of an integrative medicine specialty. The Arizona Center’s executive director Victoria Maizes, MD clarified that the move is part of a “both/and” focus for the Center.  They are still promoting an overall transformation toward an integrative model. The 20 Voices also stimulated this follow-up discussion by an anti-CAM/IM blogger who celebrates the apparent divisiveness of the move.  

Image

Daniel Redwood, DC: Balanced remarks

Comment: This is not capital “P” policy but is certainly core policy inside the integrative practice community. The topic is like a natural therapeutic regime that successfully surfaces both entrenched morbidity and abiding hope. My sincere intent
is that the perspectives registered in these Integrator postings
will lead those establishing ABIM to more deeply embrace the emerging
discipline’s most transformational potential. This means an enhanced
focus on the interprofessional education that a
patient-centered approach requires. This will address the critical
interprofessional concerns directly and indirectly note by many. Many who can’t sit for the BCIM are not yet sure that
historic and continuing political-economic suppression of other
disciplines by medical doctors will not be furthered, again, by the emerging
guild of MD-BCIMs. Or, as the framing keeps coming to me, should these professionals listen when they are told we are not like all the others

Image

US Senator Amy Klobuchar

Congressional Wellness Caucus established, linked to National Prevention Strategy

US Senator Amy Klobuchar(D-MN) and US Representative Erik Paulson (R-MN) have announced the creation of the Congressional Wellness Caucus.
The focus is “to put workplace wellness on the national agenda,”
according to an article on the June kick-off. Despite well-researched
savings associated with wellness programs, “only about 27 percent of
employers with 500 or more employees offer wellness programs and about
43 percent with 10,000 or more do” according to
the
article.
The timing of the creation of the Wellness Caucus was within 2 weeks of the publication of the National Prevention Strategy via the National Prevention Council (see article below).

Image

Congressman Erik Paulsen

The
caucus, expected to be fully functional by this fall, was referenced in
a November 1, 2011 Congressional briefing that was led by Trust for America’s Health (TfAH). Notably, the executive director of TfAH, Jeffrey Levi, PhD, serves as chair of the Advisory Group on Prevention, Health Promotion and Integrative and Public Health that advises on the above-mentioned National Prevention Strategy. Participants
in the Congressiional briefing included representatives of the Robert Wood Johnson
Foundation, National Business Coalition on Health and the Alliance for a
Healthier Minnesota.
Joining the Minnesota co-founders in the bi-partisan Caucus are Sen. John Thune (R-SD) and Rep. Ron Kind (D-WI). (Thanks to  the Integrated Healthcare Policy Consortium for bringing the November event to my attention.) 

Image

Janet Kahn, PhD

Obama appoints Janet Kahn and Dean Ornish to the Advisory Group to the National
Prevention Council



In an October 7, 2011 announcement, Barack Obama
appointed Janet Kahn, PhD to the Advisory Group on Prevention, Health Promotion and
Integrative and Public Health
of the National Prevention Council. This was followed by a November 2 announcement of 4 additional members, including Dean Ornish, MD. Kahn has been a
leading advocate for integrative practices and a health-focused delivery system
through her service as executive director of the Integrated Healthcare Policy Consortium which
nominated her for the post. Author-researcher Ornish is well-known for his pioneering research with the Preventive Medicine Research Institute in developing his presently Medicare-covered lifestyle program for reversing atherosclerosis.

Comment: This brings to 4 the number of individuals closely connected to the integrative practice fields to gain
appointment to the Advisory Group. The first were Charlotte Kerr, RSM, BSN, MPH, MAc, an
emeritus faculty member at Tai Sophia Institute and UCLA-based integrative medical doctor Sharon Van Horn, MD. The Advisory Group, charged with assisting the Council in developing the nation’s prevention and
health promotion strategy, was mandated to include integrative practitioners.

Image

Partners for Health expands

Integrated Healthcare Policy Consortium update: Partners for Health expands

The Integrated Healthcare Policy Consortium (IHPC- http://www.ihpc.info) is celebrating the appointment of senior associate and past executive director Janet Kahn, PhD, to the Advisory Group of the National Prevention, Health Promotion and Public Health Council. According to an IHPC release from chair Len Wisneski, MD,
Kahn, a researcher and practicing massage therapist, is expected to
have a significant role in shaping the nation’s relationship to
integrative care from her position on the Advisory Group.  Meantime, IHPC has announced new members of its diverse Partners for Health program. The current list includes the following, with those relatively new in italic:

  • American Academy of Pain Management
  • American Association for Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine
  • American Association of Naturopathic Physicians
  • American Massage Therapy Association
  • Bastyr University
  • International Chiropractic Pediatric Association
  • National Association of Certified Professional Midwives
  • National Center for Homeopathy
  • Naturopathic Medical Student Association
  • Oregon College of Oriental Medicine
  • Palmer College Center for Chiropractic Research
  • Sojourners Community Health Clinic 
  • Tai Sophia Institute

Image

New IHPC Partner

Comment: It is pleasing that Kahn will
continue to work with IHPC in her Senior Adviser capacity. She helped
IHPC accomplish a good deal as executive director in an environment of
great scarcity. Kahn extended herself personally in many ways. She had a
key role in placing licensed complementary and alternative healthcare
practitioners in the nation’s workforce planning, via her home state connection with US Senator Bernie Sanders.
Meantime, this is a nice group of Partners for Health! Here’s a wish
that some philanthropist or corporation with skin in this game will
realize how much fun and value could come from jumping in and empowering
this group with some real cash!

ImageIntegrative medicine at TEDMED 2011 (not), plus a changed venue to influence policy in 2012

I place the TEDMED conference under Policy because of a decision by the new owner of the brand, Jay Walker. The billionaire TEDMED curator known as the founder of Priceline has announced that this influential gathering of medical innovators will be moving next year. TEDMED leaves its cozy, community-enhancing 2009-2011 home at San Diego’s luxury Hotel Del Coronado

for the Kennedy Center in Washington, DC. Explains Walker: “Holding
TEDMED’s annual conference at the health and medicine capital
of the world will amplify the voice of the TEDMED community, bringing
TEDMED to a larger stage where the members of our community can provide a
much-needed national service.” TEDMED 2012 will be in the heart of the nation’s Beltway and also a half-year earlier, April 11-13, 2012.


Under Walker’s leadership this year, integrative medicine saw diminished visibility at TEDMED. The first two years
featured 1-3 presentations from the pantheon of the most visible
integrative medical doctors and authors. Andrew Weil, MD, Dean Ornish, MD, Deepak Chopra, MD, Mehmet Oz, MD and
Mark Hyman, MD each presented, some in multiple years. No integrative MD was on the TEDMED 2011 program for the
estimated 850 participants. Mycologist and author Paul Stamets was as good as it got for integrative practice.  

Image

Walker: TEDMED curator

Comment: The barrier to entry
for TEDMED is high, at $4000 per person. I was gifted an opportunity to
attend the October 25-28, 2011 meeting. I will report the excitement
and sometimes disturbing trend-lines more fully soon. Walker, whose
passion for the history of innovation is infectious, noted during closing
comments that some attendees had told him that the 2011 iteration “left out the
patient perspective.” Walker said he’d bring it back. Here’s hoping that his concept of innovation is broad enough to include the
substantial cultural innovation engaged by the patient population when human beings as healthcare consumers co-conspired with diverse practitioners to invent the holistic and
complementary and alternative healthcare disciplines. I understand that Walker is personally supportive of integrative medicine. Hopefully TEDMED’s obvious high-tech strengths will have more high-touch balance in 2012.

Image

Lori Knutson, RN, BC-HN

Knutson calls for community response on academic curriculum for US Preventive Service Task Force


Lori Knutson, RN, BC-HN, is an integrative care educator and the
integrative health leader for the nation’s most significant health
system-based integration initiative, Allina Hospitals and Clinics. Knutson sends notice that the US Preventive Service Task Force (USPSTF) is seeking information on what should be considered
in its “development of academic curriculum as it relates to
prevention
.” I asked Knutson for her perspective on why the integrative health community should participate. She wrote:

“This is a cultural imperative. If we are serious about
influencing the health of our nation and integrating ‘CAM’ in
the tapestry of care then we must not only focus on delivering services and
researching outcomes and best practice. We must
proactively embed this work in academic institutions so
that integrative care/medicine/health is the norm and not the exception for
healthcare provider education. The U.S. Preventive Services Task force is
asking for feedback on how to improve the academic training of healthcare
providers to ensure health promotion and prevention as having equal
relevance to the academic focus on treatment of disease and
illness.  I propose we have an obligation to be active partners in
ensuring this.

The link to the USPSTF is here. The link on the curriculum is here.


Cost & Business

Image

Mathew David, MPH, DC

NCCAM-funded Dartmouth researcher Mathew Davis reports $$$ in CAM market 

In a paper delivered at the Annual Research Meeting of AcademyHealth, Mathew Davis, MPH, DC reported useful data on the size of the CAM market and consumer spending. According to this article in Family Practice News, Davis found that:

  • visits to chiropractors fell from about 110 million in
    2005 to just under 100 million in 2008
  • spending on CAM services increased from about $8 billion in 2002
    to $8.6 billion in 2008
  • spending on CAM is concentrated in a minority of users, with
    about 25% accounting for 72% of spending
  • heavier spenders (those who spent $520-$10,000 in
    2007) aren’t any sicker than light spenders (those who spent less
    than $87)
  • in 2007, the
    top 10% of users, accounting for almost half of expenditures,
    spent a mean of $2,392.


Davis also reported that for 2007: $165 million was
spent on homeopathy, $271 million on naturopathy, $103 million on
traditional healers, $19 million on ayurveda, $567 million on herbals
and other nonvitamin supplements, $32 million on chelation, and $74
million on hypnosis.
Overall, Davis reportedly concluded that CAM accounts for less than 1% of total
health care spending in the U.S. and
remains largely “remains a cottage industry.”
(Thanks to Glenn Sabin for tipping me to this article.)

Image

Dan Church, PhD

Bastyr University reports $136-million of economic impact in 2010

An October 12, 2011 release from Bastyr University
announced that a consultant to the multidisciplinary institution in
natural health sciences generated $136-million of economic impact for
Seattle-area community in 2010.  The report from Hebert Research examined economic activity in 5 areas: operations, investment
projects, teaching clinic, spending by students and economic activity generated by local alumni. In the release,
Bastyr president Daniel Church, PhD states: “We
are proud that Bastyr University, which began over thirty years ago as a
fledgling professional school with about 30 students, has experienced the type
of growth reported in this important study.”
Copies of the full report are available through Derek Wing:

dwing@bastyr.edu.

Comment: Brilliant move to commission this report. This is no homeopathic dose.

ImageCHP Group offers concise resource on evidence, cost-effectiveness of CAM

A 20-page resource entitled “Integrating Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine into the Healthcare System” is available as a PDF file from Portland, Oregon-based CHP Group.
CHP Group uses the document in its outreach to prospective employer and
insurer clients. CHPs manages networks of chiropractors,
naturopathic doctors, acupuncturists and massage therapists. A key
client is Kaiser Northwest Permanente.
The referenced document, with 32 useful end-notes, seeks to make a case
that “research has demonstrated the clinical effectiveness of many CAM
interventions and recent studies have shown that CAM is cost-effective.”
The firm, co-founded by medical director Chuck Simpson, DC and led by Michelle Hay, CEO, was named Carrier
of the Year at the August 2011 meeting of the Oregon Association of
Health Underwriters
(OAHU) for “exceptional leadership in the
health insurance industry.”

Comment: While published in 2010, this CHP document may be useful to more than one Integrator reader.

ImageMassage education and services firm Steiner Leisure purchases Cortiva Group

On October 12, 2011, Steiner Leisure Limited announced an agreement for the acquisition of the assets of

Cortiva Group.
Cortiva was a venture-backed roll-up of seven of the nation’s most
influential for-profit massage schools with 12 campuses in Arizona,
Florida, Illinois, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Pennsylvania and
Washington. Revenues in 2010 were approximately $24.6
million. Post-closing, Steiner will own
and operate a total of 30 campuses in 14 states with an anticipated
total population of approximately 5,200 students. Steiner president and
CEO
Leonard Fluxman said:
“The acquisition of Cortiva Institute, a well-known participant in the
massage therapy education field and one of our longtime competitors,
would considerably expand and fortify the presence of our Schools
division in the post-secondary massage therapy school market.” The sale price was $33-million.

Comment: Interestingly, this move
brings into one large corporation the 2 branches of the massage field.
Cortiva’s mix has leaned involvement in medical massage, integrated care
and research involvement while Steiner’s core have a focus on the spa
services and cruise ships that are the public corporation’s Steiner’s
forte. Fluxman captures the duality this way: “We look forward to
introducing even more graduates, with increasingly
diverse skill sets, into the growing massage therapy and spa
industries.” Here’s hope there is a vital exchange between the spa and
medical interests.
(Thanks to Jan Schwartz, MA for the link to this story.)


Integrative Centers


ImageArticle surveys role of philanthropists in integrative medicine

Integrative center consultant Glenn Sabin of FON Therapeutics has offered up his reflections on the Evolution of Philanthropy in Integrative Medicine.
He supports applying philanthropic dollars to performing research,
community outreach and for educational purposes. However, while he
believes he “will take some heat for this,” Sabin argues that
philanthropically subsidizing
integrative clinical services “for all but the indigent or those that
cannot afford to pay is unsustainable as a clinic/business model.” He
points out that this can
be “a costly long-term decision that has over time resulted in the
closing of many integrative medicine programs.”

Comment: It is almost impossible to
imagine the integrative medicine movement without thinking of
philanthropy and philanthropists. What other medical fields are as
cobbled to, energized through, and hobbled by, this need? Meantime, as I
note in comments on Sabin’s piece, the creation of the holistic
medicical, naturopathic, chiropractic and other clinics that predated
the invention of integrative centers were and remain of an opposite ilk.
These
necessarily followed the Jim Henson’s toddler’s motto: I can do it. I can do it myself!

Fascinating to consider where we would be now had, say, 50% of the
philanthropic millions used as battering rams to break down the
antagonism in hospitals and academic health systems been re-directed.
What if these dollars were strategically used to empower for those whose
sweat equity created the response to patient demand known as “CAM” and
holism? Some of us are working on this going forward and will be happy
to increasingly find partners! There has clearly been value in top-down philanthropy. Be smart to have some more bottom-up, empowering these other disciplines and and providers toward integrative leadership. 


Academic Medicine

Image

Margaret Chesney, PhD

UCSF’s Margaret Chesney, PhD in line to chair the Consortium of Academic Health Centers for Integrative Medicine

Integrative medicine leader at the UCSF Osher Center director Margaret Chesney, PhD has been selected as the new vice-chair of the Consortium of Academic Health Centers for Integrative Medicine

(CAHCIM). Chesney was formerly the deputy director of the NIH National
Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine when founding director Stephen Straus, MD
was in decline with brain cancer. As CAHCIM vice chair, Chesney is
expected to succeed Ben Kligler, MD, MPH in late 2013. Kligler’s term as
chair just began. Adam Perlman, MD, MPH, director of the integrative
medicine program at Duke, just completed his term.

Image

Beau Anderson, PhD, LAc

Licensed acupuncturist Beau Anderson, PhD, LAc in academic appointment at Albert Einstein medical school

I recently became aware of the appointment of Belinda (Beau) Anderson, PhD, MAOM, LAc as assistant clinical professor at Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Yeshiva University. Anderson, academic dean and research director at Pacific College of Oriental Medicine

(PCOM), New York, is among the first licensed acupuncturists to receive
such an appointment. She shared the following educational
responsibilities that come with the title:


  • As part of an educational exchange program, 1st year Einstein students
    in the Introduction to Clinical Medicine course attend Anderson’s introductory lecture
    about Chinese medicine. They also attend a clinic shift at
    the PCOM student clinic. (In addition, a group of PCOM interns attends an introductory
    lecture followed by a three-hour cadaver dissection lab at Einstein.)

  • Anderson teaches a workshop on stress reduction called “The Use of Integrative
    Medicine” in the clinical examination section of Einstein’s Introduction to Clinical
    Medicine course.
  • Family practice residents at New York Beth Israel, an Einstein-affiliated residency
    program, attend a lecture of Anderson’s and then shadow licensed acupuncturists
    in the PCOM clinic during their 2nd year of training.


Anderson, a researcher by prior professional experience, is also
involved in a series of NIH grant submissions with members of the
Einstein faculty including Paul Marantz, MD and Ben Kligler, MD, MPH.

Comment: Among the pleasures of this
work is noting these historic moments, quiet breakthroughs,
stones dropped in ponds, as the choices of patients and the actions of
professionals begin to be reflected in the practice of institutions.
Kudos to Marantz and Kligler for facilitating this door opening and to Anderson for having the skill sets to step through .

Media

Image

Steve Jobs

Steve Jobs decision to delay conventional treatment to explore alternative medicine spins through media

“Did alternative medicine kill Steve Jobs?” This question was asked in a
flurry of articles that came out subsequent to the death of Apple
founder Steve Jobs. In fact, search that title and page after page will
show up. One headlines asks more specifically if Vegan quackery” was the culprit.
Jobs chose to explore alternatives before his surgery, allowing the
tumor to grow. The media brouhaha led NIH NCCAM director Josephine
Briggs, MD to publish a comment on it on her Director’s Page. Briggs takes a view that the evidence is not there for using CAM in
lieu of conventional treatment. She adds that complementary approaches
can be useful in the areas of quality of life, giving patients active
participation and
empowerment, and alleviating the symptoms and side
effects.

Integrator columnist Taylor Walsh notes that a CNN feature in
which
Anderson Cooper and Sanjay Gupta discussed
the topic “was very balanced noting that many patients choose
anything-but-surgery treatments.” He adds: “Did
not seem much for the quacklings to latch on to.” Walsh notes that the
discussion on Jobs’ cancer starts on chapter
35, page 452 of Walter Isaacson’s book, “Steve Jobs.” He provides these relevant notes:

  • Jobs, a vegan,
    had “… obsessive diets and weird routines of purging and fasting that he
    had practiced since he was a teenager.”

  • Jobs’
    reluctance to go with surgery when first diagnosed with the pancreatic cancer
    drove his friends and advisors crazy. 
    This included former Intel chairman Andy Grove, who had surgery for
    prostate cancer and overcame it.

  • “Even
    diet doctor Dean Ornish, a pioneer in alternative and nutritional methods of
    treating diseases, took a long walk with Jobs and insisted that sometimes
    traditional methods were the right option. ‘You really need the surgery,’
    Ornish told him.”

  • Once
    diagnosed, in addition to his diet, “he added acupuncture, a variety of
    herbal remedies and occasionally a few other treatments he found on the
    Internet…for a while he was under the sway of a doctor who operated a natural
    healing clinic in southern California that stressed the use of organic herbs,
    juice fasts, frequent bowel cleansings, hydrotherapy, and the expression of all
    negative feelings.”

Image

Taylor Walsh: Comments on issue

  • When the
    surgery was done 9 months after diagnosis, it involved removal of part of the
    pancreas, which, according to Isaacson’s text, meant his pancreas would would
    produce less protein: “Patients are advised to make sure that they eat
    frequent meals and maintain a nutritious diet, with a wide variety of meat and
    fish proteins as well as full-fat milk products.  Jobs had never done this, and he never
    would.”

  • When Isaacson discussed the book with Charlie Rose last
    week, Rose asked several times basically if anyone was responsible for giving
    Jobs bad health advice.  Isaacson would
    not bite and repeated that Jobs’ health choices reflected his lifelong
    attitudes and lifestyles.

  • In the book he quoted Apple board member Art Levinson,
    also chairman of Genentech: “I think Steve has such a strong desire for
    the world to be a certain way that he wills it to be that way.  Sometimes it doesn’t work.  Reality is unforgiving.”


Taylor Walsh Comments
: “Without wishing to overstate it, Jobs’ experience in some ways
illustrates the state of integrative medicine in the
2000’s: moving toward a rational balance perhaps, but
still characterized by fragmentation and dissonance among the voices of
the
disciplines. Not
everyone can take a walk with Dean Ornish. Even
so, one can only do so much for a hardheaded iconoclast
like Jobs, whose brilliance was often ascribed to perpetual ‘magical
thinking.’


Research

Image

Karen Sherman, PhD

Sherman/Cherkin Group Health group finds both yoga and stretching better than usual care

The productive Group Health Research Institute group led by Karen Sherman, PhD and  Daniel Cherkin, PhD report that yoga classes are effective in treating low back pain. The study was published as A Randomized Trial Comparing Yoga, Stretching, and a Self-care Book for Chronic Low Back Pain
in Archives of Internal Medicine. However, the researchers concluded that while “yoga
classes were more effective than a self-care book” these were “not more
effective than stretching classes, in improving function and reducing
symptoms due to chronic low back pain.” In both stretching and yoga, benefits were found to last “at least
several months.” I asked Yoga therapist John Kepner, executive director of the International Association of Yoga Therapists, for his perspective on why the yoga classes were not better than stretching classes. He wrote:

“Re sham/stretching and yoga


“1. Karen (Sherman) had a good explanation – that the stretching
classes
were more “Yoga like” than the typical exercise program. “We expected
back pain to ease more with yoga than with stretching, so our
findings surprised us,” Dr. Sherman said. “The most straightforward
interpretation of our findings would be that yoga’s benefits on back
function
and symptoms were largely physical, due to the stretching and
strengthening of
muscles.” But the stretching classes included a lot more stretching
than in most such
classes, with each stretch held for a relatively long time. “People may
have
actually begun to relax more in the stretching classes than they would
in a
typical exercise class,” she added. “In retrospect, we realized that
these
stretching classes were a bit more like yoga than a more typical
exercise
program would be.” So the
trial might have compared rather similar programs with each other.


“2. But note, this study was focused on a very narrow definition of
benefits, (reducing chronic low back pain). Yet the classical goal of
Yoga is mental health, i.e., quieting the mind. The tangible and
demonstrable integration of body breath and mind in a classic Yoga practice is
focused on that. That was not measured here. 


“3. When I ask my personal students the primary reason they come to
Yoga class, the ‘benefits’ if you will, they will not say reducing
pain.  They say ‘defragging’ their brain, which I interpret as
simply expressing the classic ‘quieting the fluctuation of the mind’  in
modern terminology.    


“4. The benefits of Yoga in reducing physical pain could be
interpreted simply as positive ‘side effects’ of the practice -although
they are not very inconsequential to a person in actual pain.” 

Image

IAYT’s John Kepner: Comments on issue

The Group Health release is here. The publication was accompanied by a commentary from a primary care provider who considered the study an “excellent example of a pragmatic comparative effectiveness trial.” He recommended that physicians refer for the yoga or stretching classes.

Comment: This findings continue an
interesting pattern from the Cherkin-Sherman team. Their examination of
acupuncture found it more effective than usual care, but no more
effective than “sham acupuncture.” An examination of massage therapy
found a focused medical massage effective and
reflection on many of our parts. It is intriguing to see Sherman’s view
that the form or stretching may have tilted toward the more reflective
and mind-slowing experience many find in yoga. Stretching can be a mind-body engagement. Meantime, Kepner’s
perspective is a fun reversal, placing the back pain benefits as positive
side effects of mind-spirit value of the Yoga therapy. A Cherkin-Sherman
paper on positive side-effects is noted here.


ImageReport published on Naturopathic Science & Policy Summit 2011

The Natural Medicine Journal has published a report on the August 2011 Naturopathic Science & Policy Summit led by the Naturopathic Physicians Research Institute (NPRI). Key conclusions:

“1. There was consensus that research toward policy objectives in the
field is essential to the profession’s identity and advancement.
Simultaneously, better focus on critical goals is needed. This means
that research on naturopathic practice, naturopathic physicians and
their patients, and naturopathic medical theory is required, and not
simply studies on single agents and modalities. Broad outcome measures
are necessary to measure the impact of naturopathic medicine on whole
health and prevention, not just biomarkers of disease progression.


“2. The most compelling work has been and will be outcomes studies in
naturopathic practice in comparison to conventional medical models,
particularly on clinical effectiveness, safety, and cost, published in
peer-reviewed journals.”

The participants in the Summit also concluded that
“financial and other resources from the profession must be accessed” to
develop the necessary information. The NMJ is the official publication of the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians, a Summit co-sponsor. (Alignment of interest note: I helped develop this meeting as a member of the NPRI board.)

Professions & Organizations

Image

US Rep. Bruce Braley

Chiropractors in bill to allow loan repayment for service in under-served areas

A late October newsletter from the American Chiropractic Association (ACA) reminded members
that their help is needed to increase sponsorship for the Access to
Frontline Healthcare Act
(HR 531). The legislation was originally
introduced February 2011 in the US House of Representatives by Rep. Bruce
Braley
(D-Iowa). It would designate certain types of health care
providers
as “frontline” providers. According to the ACA, the association and the
Association of Chiropractic Colleges worked closely with the Braley “to
ensure that chiropractic physicians are specified in the
bill as qualifying for this status.” A draft letter is available at
the ACA’s Legislative Action Center.

New Hampshire Republicans buck leadership to join Democrats in supporting coverage mandate for naturopathic doctors 


The New Hampshire Business Review ran an October 21, 2011 article entitled House panel endorses naturopaths mandate
that documents a break by Republican members against the wish of the Republican
committee chair. These joined with Democrats in a 15-5 vote in support of the
requirement that insurers cover the state’s licensed naturopathic doctors. Debate
broke over mandates versus choice. The deciding argument was that
insurers “already pay for primary care
physicians, so they will be paying for this instead.” A Democrat chimed in
that “insurers would
probably pay less, since naturopathic doctors would be less likely to
prescribe expensive drugs and recommend high-tech medical intervention.

A mandate already exists in nearby Vermont where naturopathic doctors
are also included as Medicaid providers. (Thanks to Pamela Snider, ND
for bringing this article to my attention.)

ImageAcupuncturists without Borders in tight spot financially

In an October 18, 2011 e-blast boldly labeled SUPPORT
NEEDED!
Acupuncturists without Borders (AWB) 
announced that it “had to cut back on our staffing temporarily until we
receive more funds, donations and membership dues.” The organization’s
mission is to “provide
immediate relief and recovery acupuncture services to global
communities that are in crisis from disaster or human conflict.” AWB says it has helped more than 20,000 people recover following
Hurricane Katrina, Iowa floods, California wildfires, Boulder wildfires,
shootings in Tucson, earthquake in New
Zealand and in recent work with traumatized
populations in Nepal, Ecuador, Mongolia, and Haiti as well as Missouri,
Minneapolis, and Springfield, Mass. after the tornadoes of
2011. Presently AWB is operating with the
equivalent of less than one paid full time staff person. Reasons are that “grants we used to get are no
longer available and donations are down due to the recession.” The
organization is urging practitioners to place AWB’s donation kit in
waiting rooms to stimulate patient support.


Image

Rebecca Snowden

Naturopathic student Rebecca
Snowden in leadership role with the American Medical Student Association
(yes, you read that right)

The committee chair for the Medical Professionalism Action Committee
of the American Medical Student Association is a naturopathic medical
student, Rebecca Snowden. The committee’s charge is, according to the web site, “to change how future physicians interact by promoting: professionalism over commercialism; Teamwork over isolation; patient-centered care over physician-centered care; Ethics awareness, integrity and professional development;
and increased physician-in-training access to medical humanities.”
Under Snowden’s direction, AMSA students will find an integrated set of
web-resources on these topics. Under the sub-heading of “Teamwork”, for instance, one sees competencies propounded by the Association of American Medical Colleges and 5 other conventional disciplines side-by-side with those from 5 licensed CAM fields.

ImageSnowden, a medical student at Southwest College of Naturopathic Medicine, explains her role this way: “ND students have been eligible to hold certain leadership
positions in AMSA for a few years now and they have a Naturopathic Medicine Interest Group
for those interested in learning more. They try to help us with
opportunities in their
conference/convention schedules to plug an ND speaker somewhere into the
line
up, such as in [integrative medicine] panels at the conferences).” She
clarifies: “Currently ND students are not accepted as ‘Medical
Student Members’ as MD and DO students are.  We are ‘Supporting
Affiliate
Members.’ This year, there are 5 of
us ND student leaders in AMSA. We are collaborating with NMSA to submit
proposals in March [2012] at the AMSA Convention House of Delegates session
asking for
an AMSA statement on Naturopathic Medicine in their Principles, to
include support for licensure, Medical Student Membership, and an
ND Advisory Board. This work has also
been happening under the mentorship of Bill Benda, MD.”


Miscellaneous

Image

Ira Zunin, MD, MPH

Hawai’i’s most significant integrative center seeks additional primary care MD

Integrator editorial adviser Ira Zunin, MD, MBA, MPH
writes: “Manakai
O Malama
Integrative Health Care Group and Rehabilitation Center is
seeking a
board certified/board eligible family physician or other primary care
provider to
join our group. Enjoy the practice of medicine in a large,
well-established,
dynamic integrative facility. Our philosophy is to bring
together the best of modern medicine and traditional healing arts with
cultural
sensitivity to optimize whole-patient outcomes. The multidisciplinary
team includes: family medicine, women’s health, psychology,
physiatry, physical therapy and acupuncture. This facility is
well-suited for
the Patient-Centered Medical Home (PCMH) and recently completed EMR
transition to
EPIC. The office is open 8-5pm M-F and 8-3pm Saturday. The position is
for a
PT/FT physician.” Contact Ira Zunin
MD Medical Director:
info@manakaiomalama.com

Comment: I recently interviewed Zunin
for a piece on integrative medicine and the PCMH which I expect to publish shortly. Manakai O Malama  appears to
be a national leader in manifesting integrative care in the PCMH
environment. An exceptional opportunity. Zunin’s work was last seen here in
the Integrator:
Ira Zunin, MD and Manakai O Malama: Checking in on a Thriving Integrative Center.  

People

Image

Christina Jackson, RN, BC-HN

Christina Jackson, PhD, RN, AHN-BC is
2011 Holistic Nurse of the Year


The American Holistic Nurses Association has selected Christina Jackson PhD, RN, PNP, AHN-BC as the Holistic Nurse of the Year for 2011. In a release the AHNA noted that Jackson, a professor of nursing at Eastern University in Pa.
“embodies holistic values and is a true leader for holistic education and
approaches to care.” Jackson
has developed holistic nursing curricula and taught
courses. Among these are: Theoretical Foundations in Professional Holistic Nursing;
Psychosocial/ Spiritual Care; Fitness Through Yoga and Pilates; and Holistic
Healthcare for Culturally Diverse Populations: Issues in Women’s Health.

Jackson is certified as a Advanced Practice Holistic Nurse through the
American Holistic Nurses Certification Corporation (AHNCC) since 2004. She is also is
a Certified Holistic Nurse through AHNCC. Eastern’s release on Jackson’s award is here.

Image

Rita Bettenburg, ND

CHP Group hires Rita Bettenburg, ND as assistant medical director

Portland Oregon-based CHP Group (formerly Complementary Healthcare Plans) has hired Rita Bettenburg, ND

as assistant medical director. Bettenburg is the former dean of
naturopathic medicine at National College of Natural Medicine and
president of the Council on Naturopathic Medical Education. The
CHP Group (CHP) offers networks of licensed CAM practitioners (chiropractic, naturopathic, acupuncture, and massage therapy) to health plans and large employers on). Bettenburg assisted the CHP Group over a decade ago in expanding its network beyond chiropractic doctors. 

Send your news to
johnweeks@theintegratorblog.com
for inclusion in a future Integrator.

Send your comments to
johnweeks@theintegratorblog.com

for inclusion in a future Your Comments Forum.
]]> 5893 Columnist Taylor Walsh: March Prevention-Madness in DC and Implications for Integrative Practice https://healthy.net/2011/04/09/columnist-taylor-walsh-march-prevention-madness-in-dc-and-implications-for-integrative-practice/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=columnist-taylor-walsh-march-prevention-madness-in-dc-and-implications-for-integrative-practice Sat, 09 Apr 2011 16:40:50 +0000 https://healthy.net/2011/04/09/columnist-taylor-walsh-march-prevention-madness-in-dc-and-implications-for-integrative-practice/ Summary: Beltway-based Integrator columnist Taylor Walsh specializes in examining policy changes with an eye on their potential meaning to integrative medicine and health care. In this column, Walsh offers a useful summary of a rash of developments as the National Prevention (and Public Health) Strategy begins to unfold. “Integrative health care” is a new concept right up front in the law behind this $16.5-billion effort. Are there explicit initiatives laid out in these plans? Walsh points to where there may be opportunity.

A major Integrator editorial interest is in following the evolution, or devolution, of activity in the Capitol relative to the integrative practice community. In this work, Washington, D.C.-based Integrator columnist Taylor Walsh is an indispensable ally. Here he informs of events relative what may ultimately be $16.5 billion of new funds for prevention and public health. This is through a new Prevention and Public Health Council with 2 representatives from our fields. The law establishing the Council has 3 references to “integrative health care” in the list of the Council’s top goals. Walsh’s report is a useful orientation.

Walsh is a consultant, entrepreneur and writer on digital media and integrative health. His blog is Getting to Integrative Health & Wellness. His Twitter account is @taylorw.

_______________________________________

March Prevention-Madness Week in DC

— Taylor Walsh


Image

Taylor Walsh

Last week was March Prevention-Madness week in Washington.


Anticipating the imminent release of the National Prevention Strategy [draft], the
health and prevention policy community held several roundtables and forums and
published articles speculating on the potential of the strategy and its
accompanying 10-year, $16.5 billion Prevention
and Public Health Fund
.  The
administration is reportedly on the cusp of issuing its first hundreds of
millions in grants scheduled for 2011.


If only we could find the National Prevention Strategy and
get started.  Due for release March 23,
the NPS, at this writing, remains unsighted. 
It has apparently “hit a snag,” probably one hammered into the wall
outside Rep. Paul Ryan’s [R-WI] office.  It is
a slightly disconcerting way to start “Moving the nation from a focus on
sickness to one of wellness and prevention” as the NPS mission statement
asserts.


In deference to policy realities – the NPS is after all a
creation of The Law – we’ll assume that the Strategy and its Fund will appear,
for this year at least.

   
“The prevention strategy appears
to be responsive to transitions
already in
place in public life.

 

 

All this focus on “prevention” may barely warrant looking up
from your appointment book, but just as the behemoth public health care
enterprise has moved at the NIH National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, elsewhere at NIH (behavior science), and through comparative effectiveness research (CER) to respond to real world demands, the prevention strategy, as part of the
Accountable Care Act itself, appears to be responsive to transitions already in
place in public life.


Defined in the 2010 ACA, the National Prevention Strategy
and its fund have had an erratic ride through its organizational and definition
process, with the first 13 members of a 25-person national advisory council
appointed after the draft of the
Strategy had been open and then closed to public comment. The Integrator Blog has reported this disconnect thoroughly.


But because the ACA embedded “integrative practice” into the language of the law and made it
explicit if not yet defined in the National Prevention Strategy, it is worth
looking at the initial areas of funding. (Two of the first 13 appointees to the
advisory council are experienced integrative practitioners: Sr. Charlotte Kerr,
RSM, MPH
and Sharon Van Horn, MD, MPH.)


The anticipated areas of focus and funding amounts were set
out last week by Jeffrey Levi, PhD, executive director of the Trust for
America’s Health
(TFAH), addressing a policy roundtable hosted by the Altarum Institute. TFAH works closely with the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.


Levi also wrote about the Fund for the Huffington Post here.  He
said a major focus of the fund are the Community
Transformation Grants
(CTGs), intended to inspire local collaborations
among “small business owners, faith leaders, youth leaders, employers,
community groups, parents, law enforcement officials, schools, and health care
providers.”  Specific targets for these
grants:

  • Improve
    nutrition and physical education programs in schools;
  • Launch
    initiatives to reduce tobacco use, especially among children and
    adolescents;
  • Improve
    access to healthful, affordable foods through farmers’ markets and by
    making fresh fruits and vegetables available in local stores

Expanding the
Prevention Paradigm?


It is notable that these areas — apart from the
ever-discouraging efforts to control smoking 
— reflect newly created, independent initiatives in place across the
country that are not traditionally part of the lexicon or programmatic
attention of the prevention and health promotion community.  This is important because — at least in
intent — these areas start to take publicly supported prevention programs
beyond their traditional boundaries.  
But it will take some crowbarring to keep them there.


Levi showed the following breakout of $1.5 billion of
anticipated funding for these categories for 2011.  The strong local focus is clear:


• Community Prevention ($298 million)


• Community and State Prevention ($222 million)


• Tobacco Prevention ($60 million)


• Obesity Prevention and Fitness ($16 million)


• Clinical Prevention ($182 million)


• Access to Critical Wellness and Preventive Health Services
($112 million)

• Behavioral Health Screening and Integration with Primary
Health ($70 million)


• Public Health Infrastructure and Training ($137 million)


• Public Health Capacity ($52 million)


• Public Health Workforce ($45 million)


• Public Health Infrastructure ($40 million)

• Research and Tracking ($133 million)


• Health Care Surveillance and Planning ($84 million)


• Prevention Research ($49 million)

   
  “This list obviously does not clearly
set out where access to
local farm
produce might be placed, for example,
or school nutrition programs,
or
other health care providers not usually

associated with clinical prevention

(community acupuncture, for instance).”

 

This list obviously does not clearly set out where access to
local farm produce might be placed, for example, or school nutrition programs,
or other health care providers not usually associated with clinical prevention
(community acupuncture, for instance).


And while viewing wellness and prevention in a broader
context is cheering, the reality reflected in the above funding categories is
depressingly old-time: we have the smallest commitment for what is quite
obviously the biggest, most serious long term health issue the country faces:
“Obesity Prevention and Fitness” – $16 million or just 1.07%.


One hopes that somebody’s computer just cut-and-pasted in
the $1.5 billion into the 2011 spreadsheet and let the pre-set formulas spit
out the dollar amounts.  (Those existing
independent local initiatives, scratching and clawing for funds and resources,
are probably many times more than $18 million already.)

After the BigJob.Gov:
Go Bipartisan


One also hopes that another initiative announced last week
will seriously adjust the percent allotted to Obesity Prevention and Fitness in
the Prevention Fund.


The Bipartian Policy Center (BPC) introduced its “Nutrition
and Physical Activity Initiative,”
a year-long effort to identify factors that
will:


  • Improve Nutrition Education (consumer messaging;
    training physicians and teachers)

  • Dismantle Barriers to Physical Activity (time
    and place; in the workplace)

  • Accelerate Availability of Nutritious Foods
    (schools and communities)

  • Harness Institutional Involvement (hospitals, national
    parks, large food preparers)


The BPC was formed in 2007 by former Senate majority leaders Baker, Mitchell, Dole
and Daschle and engages former senior federal agency and congressional leaders
to take on from the outside what they were constrained from doing while in
government. Other areas of focus: transportation, energy, national security
and democracy.

The “Nutrition and Physical Activity Initiative” is led by
two former Agriculture secretaries: Dan Glickman and Ann Veneman (both of whom
who attended); and two former HHS secretaries: Donna Shalala and Mike Leavitt. 


This event drew a large audience from the physical
education, nutrition and food, and parks and rec sectors, including Michelle
Obama’s White House food coordinator. 
Massachusetts Congressman James McGovern recommended that the White
House convene a conference on Food and Nutrition (which was of interest to at
least one attendee who was at the last such conference, in 1969.)

   
“The initiative will clearly attempt
to aggregate the
experiences that

are being created in individual
communities but whose stories
are

not well known …”

.

 

Glickman, who MC’d the event, noted: “There are many
good things going on.”  The job, he
said, will be to “identify what works and scale-up the good ones.” Worksite
wellness programs were inevitably mentioned. Anne Veneman was emphatic about
the potential for improving nutrition awareness: “Teach nutrition education (in
K-12),” she said.  “Put in school
gardens; teach the science of growing food.”


The process will include local public forums, white papers,
and other data collection efforts that will result in a set of “comprehensive,
actionable” policy recommendations in early 2012. 


The initiative will clearly attempt to aggregate the
experiences that are being created in individual communities but whose stories
are not well known outside those communities. 
This is a commendable activity, and necessary to give prevention and
wellness an underlying cohesion on which more can be built; despite the errors
in spreadsheet data entry (one hopes).

   
  “There
appears to be an opportunity

this year to stretch ‘integrative practice’
from
the language of the Accountable
Care Act and the National Prevention
Strategy to these public forums on
prevention and wellness.”

 

While you may respond to this account with “enough with all this Washington hoodoo,” if you are providing services in local settings it could
be worth following the BPC and NPS programs. 
They will be on the ground in communities around the country.  The first public forum to be held by BPC’s
Nutrition and Exercise Initiative will be held at the University of Miami,
April 20.   


It is possible that their representatives may arrive with
preconceived notions about what constitutes prevention.  Or the local event may well be a creation of
the local community.  Either way, there
appears to be an opportunity this year to stretch “integrative practice” from
the language of the Accountable Care Act and the National Prevention Strategy
(wherever it is) to these public forums on prevention and wellness.

Comment: Walsh’s report, and conclusion, underscore a truism in politics. Any significant appreciation of how “integrative health care” and “integrative health” may represent new models and new ways of thinking in the new prevention and health promotion plan will be largely absent unless the integrative practice community actively educates the relevant regulators.

For reference, these are the footholds for integrative health right up front, in the “Purposes and Duties” in Section 4001 of the A.C.A.:


    (1) provide coordination and leadership at the Federal
    level, and among all Federal departments and agencies, with respect to
    prevention, wellness and health promotion practices, the public health
    system, and integrative health care in the United States;


    (2) after obtaining input from relevant stakeholders,
    develop a national prevention, health promotion, public health, and
    integrative health care strategy
    that incorporates the most effective
    and achievable means of improving the health status of Americans and
    reducing the incidence of preventable illness and disability in the
    United States;


    (3) provide recommendations to the President and
    Congress concerning the most pressing health issues confronting the
    United States and changes in Federal policy to achieve national
    wellness, health promotion, and public health goals, including the
    reduction of tobacco use, sedentary behavior, and poor nutrition;


    (4) consider and propose evidence-based models,
    policies, and innovative approaches for the promotion of transformative
    models of prevention, integrative health, and public health on
    individual and community levels across the United States …

    Send your comments to
    johnweeks@theintegratorblog.com

    for inclusion in a future Your Comments Forum.
    ]]> 5868 Integrative Medicine and Integrated Health Care Round-up #40 February 2011 https://healthy.net/2011/02/13/integrative-medicine-and-integrated-health-care-round-up-40-february-2011/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=integrative-medicine-and-integrated-health-care-round-up-40-february-2011 Sun, 13 Feb 2011 18:46:46 +0000 https://healthy.net/2011/02/13/integrative-medicine-and-integrated-health-care-round-up-40-february-2011/ Summary: The Institute for Functional Medicine begins state of Florida-backed $1.2-million pilot with Tallahassee residency program … Holistic Primary Care survey finds holistic and conventional practices converging … Graduates of University of Arizona IM Fellowship struggling to establish IM practices, survey finds … Integrative practice organizations urge additional integrative health expertise before finalizing National Prevention (and Health Promotion) Strategy … Obama appoints acupuncturist-nurse Charlotte Rose Kerr to “integrative practitioner” slot for National Prevention Council Advisory Group … No integrative health researchers named to PCORI Methodology Committee, despite Congressional intent … Former Duke IM leader Tracy Gaudet, MD appointed to head up new national VA office … Integrated Healthcare Policy Consortium offers policy-makers a statement relative to integrative practitioners in workforce planning … InteractionsGuide.com developer Mitch Stargrove, ND, LAc named to leadership group for HRSA pharmacy initiative … Council of Colleges of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine publishes strategic priorities … “Integration” used as a draw for prospective students at New York Chiropractic College … Boucher Institute of Naturopathic Medicine seeks new president … Philanthropic organizations invited by team Samueli-Kellogg-Ripple team to explore an integrative medicine interest group at upcoming Grantmakers in Health conference … National College of Natural Medicine receives $1.35 million from from owners of Bob’s Red Mill organic foods … Integrated Chiropractic Outcomes Network created to capture real world outcomes, including health and wellness … New Yorker article by Atul Gawande highlights role of health coaches … Swiss government reverses, will test 5 key “CAM” practices’ NCCAM may be arbiter … James Wheedon, DC examines possible data biasing in Medicare chiropractic demonstration project … Peter D’Adamo to offer May 2011 Generative Medicine seminar … Minnesota Medicine runs Bill Manahan, MD’s health reform suggestions, originally published in early 2009 in the Integrator …



Integrative Practice

Image

Work to create pilots comes to fruition

Institute for Functional Medicine begins $1.2-million Florida state-backed clinical pilot with Tallahassee family medicine program

On January 21, 2011, the Gig Harbor, Washington-based Institute for Functional Medicine (IFM) announced a collaboration between IFM
and the Tallahassee Memorial Family Medicine Residency Program (FMRP). The collaboration,
funded
by a
$1.2 million grant from the Florida Agency for Health Care
Administration
, will be a pilot project to “establish a Medical Symptom
Reduction Clinic utilizing the
functional medicine model and a chronic-care team approach for patient
care.” The project, according to the release, will “integrate functional medicine/nutrition into [the residency’s] curriculum and
clinical activities.”

Image

Florida agency supports project

One area of investigation includes “personalized
care for individuals with chronic disease, particularly for vulnerable
patients recently discharged from the hospital.” Key outcome measures
are potential reductions in ER usage and hospitalizations. The project
will be headed up by FMRP behavioral medicine faculty member Cathy
Snapp, PhD. The team also includes Narayanan
Krishnamurthy, MD, Phillip Treadwell, PharmD, Dean Watson, MD and Ruth
DeBusk, PhD, RD, IFM’s lead faculty member for its functional nutrition
course. In addition,
IFM faculty members Rich Panico, MD and Michael Stone, MD, MS will be consultants.

Comment:  This breakthrough project is
more thoroughly described here in the release. This appears to be a model to potentially emulate. Take a look.
Congratulations to IFM, the leaders of which have been promising a
development like this since publication of their exceptional white paper 21st Century Medicine.Fun to see Panico involved. His integrative medicine leadership at Athens (Georgia) Regional Medical Center was featured in this Integrator article


Image

Upbeat on survey results

Holistic Primary Care finds “convergence of conventional and holistic medicine” in physician survey

An article in the Winter 2010 issue of Holistic Primary Care contains results of a 52 item survey of 2000 primary care doctors (9%
response rate) across the United States. Core finding: “The numbers tell us that
nearly 80% of all primary care practitioners
are incorporating some modalities from holistic or ‘alternative’
medicine into their practices, with nutrition counseling and stress
management being most common. Many are getting into functional medicine,
botanical medicine, and acupuncture. One-fifth … are using some
form of hands-on manual technique with your patients.”

The survey was sent to practitioners who routinely receive HPC. Of the respondents: 78% were MDs,
12% DOs, and
the remainder NDs, DCs, nurses and others; 62% were men; and the average
age was 50. Over half of the respondents surveyed said they use
information from HPC in their practices and one-third have it available
in their waiting rooms. The  synopsis on the HPC site notes that while
supplement prescription is growing, roughly a third of respondents reported having seen
a significant adverse reaction to supplement use. The full survey
outcomes, which also includes data on practice patterns, is available for purchase here.

Comment: The sample selected for this survey and the low response rate each urge caution on extrapolations to the broader primary care population. Still, these data, and the spin on them, are interesting.

Image

Graduates of IM Fellowship surveyed

Survey of recent graduates of the University of Arizona IM Fellowship finds many struggling to create practices

Duke Primary Care physician Richard Schneider, MD, a recent graduate of the Fellowship in Integrative Medicine at the University of Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine, found
difficulties in developing an integrative medicine practice after he
completed his program. He wondered how his fellow graduates were doing. Schneider
surveyed 27 of them.
In a report entitled Integrative Medicine: The Spirit is Willing, Schneider shares that

23% were in integrative practices, about 50% were “in planning stages”,
and those in the other quarter were “thinking about it.” Schneider, a medical director in the Duke system where integrative medicine investment has been relatively high, concludes: “The results are quite encouraging, but not without caveats to
the development of an IM practice.” The top obstacle was reimbursement with the second “time constraints.”

Image

Schneider: Checking in with the success of his other Fellows

Schneider’s report
includes information on the barriers and ideas where the Fellows need to
focus attention to foster the development of their integrative medicine
practices. Schneider is medical director at Duke Primary Care’s Creedmoor Road Clinic and is co-founder and faculty at CoHvation, which he describes as “a think-tank for collaborative
healthcare innovations which seeks to assist and promote Integrative Medicine
practice in both the in and out patient setting.


Comment
: Schneider’s findings recalled to mind
survey data on practices of licensed acupuncturists in
which significant under-employment was found. My sense is that many
naturopathic medical graduates are similarly under-utilized. Detractors may conclude that the problem is that these services don’t work, otherwise
they’d draw patients, wouldn’t they? Advocates will say that time and
money (reimbursement and constraints) are significant obstacles; challenges with business models
has little to do with the potential health care value of these practices. Meantime, I
wonder how long spirits across these fields will remain willing if
something doesn’t give. The best hope on the horizon are practical pilots such as that which appears to be modeled by IFM in Tallahassee (see article this Round-up).


Policy

Image

Surgeon General Benjamin: Urged to take more integrative health input

Integrative practice organizations find holes in draft National Prevention Strategy, urge more community input

In
the short, holiday-filled December 23-January 13 (then 18) time-frame for public input to the National
Prevention, Health Promotion and Public Health Council’s draft National
Prevention (and Health Promotion) Strategy
, some in the integrative
practice community found time to respond. Among those
submitting: Samueli Institute, Integrated Healthcare Policy
Consortium, American Chiropractic Association, American Association
of Naturopathic Physicians, National Center for Homeopathy and various individuals. These perspectives, published as a group here, yield the following key themes.

  • Appoint the Advisory Group of community experts, including those expert in “integrative health care” specifically noted in the law.

  • Change
    the title: National Prevention Strategy says more of the same. 
  • The present definitions and approaches are too limited if you want the transformational outcome asserted.
  • Explore the value in primary prevention and health promotion of integrative practices and practitioners.
  • Use emerging community and self-care resources.

  • Engage in integrative practice research that has health and wellness outcomes.
  • Bear in mind that the ultimate national strategy that will be transformational will rely on research we need to first engage.

Image

Jonas: Draft still not health focused

Comment: By sharing their perspectives publicly, these integrative practice
organizations
allow us to begin
to see where common themes emerge and lines of continuity exist. Thanks
to each of these organizations and individuals for sharing. My own conclusion, more harsh than these, is that the Council must dramatically slow its time-table. Otherwise it will not successfully engage what the draft declares in the first sentence as “the unprecedented opportunity to shift the nation from a focus on sickness and disease to one based on wellness and prevention.” The focus of the draft strategy, as Samueli Institute CEO Wayne Jonas, MD summarized in a note to the Integrator, “still seems to on
preventing death rather than improving
health.” The document needs significant work or the outcomes will fall far short of the goal.


Related Integrator articles:

Image

Kerr: Sole integrative health practitioner on key panel

Charlotte Kerr, RN, MPH, LAc appointed to Advisory Group on Prevention, Health Promotion and Integrative and Public Health

Note: As of February 3, 10 positions have yet to be named. The integrative

health care community still has a chance for more representation. Among those nominated
are Wayne Jonas, MD (Samueli) and Janet Kahn, PhD (IHPC). Keep pressing!


On January 26, 2011, President Barack Obama announced 14 members of the Advisory Group to the Council on Prevention, Health Promotion, and Integrative and Public Health. Congress mandated that this group include at least one integrative practitioner. Filling that bill for the Council is Charlotte Rose Kerr, RSM, RN, BSN, MPH, MAc (UK), LAc, DiplAc (NCCAOM), a former member of the faculty at Tai Sophia Institute.
This is Kerr’s second presidential appointment. In 1999, Bill Clinton appointed her to the White House Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medicine Policy. Kerr also served a term on the advisory committee of the NIH Office of Alternative Medicine and was among the group of integrative health leaders who testified before Congress on February 23, 2009 in the days leading up to the Institute of Medicine Summit on Integrative Medicine. (Kerr’s testimony is here.) 

Comment: Never mind, for a moment, that this Advisory Group was appointed after the National Prevention Strategy was drafted and the public comment period closed. Comments on the draft National Prevention Strategy by organizations associated with integrative practice, as noted above, called for more input from the integrative practice community and specifically for appointment of the Advisory Group before the Strategy is finalized.

Kerr is a familiar face representing CAM/IM in the Beltway. I can’t think of anyone else with such a scope of appointments. Yet, to my knowledge, Kerr hasn’t thus far viewed those positions as a responsibility to network deeply with the expertise that surrounds her in the integrative health world to best inform her work as a public servant. I may have missed something. Here’s hoping that Kerr will do all she can to connect with and gather ideas from these community experts for whom she may be the one-and-only obvious point of access. Congratulations, Charlotte, and good luck with this “the unprecedented opportunity to shift the
nation from a focus on sickness and disease to one based on wellness and
prevention.”

Image

Was Congressional intent side-stepped?

Integrative health community researchers shut out from appointments to the PCORI Methodology Committee

The January 21, 2011 announcement of appointees to the critically important Methodology Committee of the Patient Centered Outcomes Research Institute (PCORI) did not include any individuals whose published biographies referenced significant experience in integrative health. The language of the enabling statute requires that PCORI’s “Expert Advisory Council(s) shall … include experts in integrative health and primary prevention strategies.” Among organizations that submitted nominations were the Integrated Healthcare Policy Consortium and the Academic Consortium for Complementary and Alternative Health Care, with which I am involved.

Comment: Following a note I sent to colleagues regarding the missing appointment of anyone deeply experience in integrative health research methods, one colleague wrote back that Brian Mittman, PhD, Director, VA Center for
Implementation Practice and Research Support, Department of Veterans
Affairs in Los Angeles “is a good guy” has some prior involvement in chiropractic research. At present, however, it would appear that the distinct experience that whole person, health-focused integrative practices might have brought into the Committee, as apparently required by Congress, were left on the appointment room floor. My auditor brother-in-law, formerly with the US General Accounting Office, once taught me about the meaning of “compliance audit.” An auditor would find non compliance here.
 

Image

Seeks to assist workforce planning

Integrated Healthcare Policy Consortium (IHPC) offers statement on meaning of “integrative practitioners” for federal policy-makers, sort of …


On January 13, 2011, the multidisciplinary Integrated Healthcare Policy Consortium published
a
press release entitled “Policy Statement on the National Healthcare
Workforce in an Era of Integration.
” 
The release responds to an opportunity and some confusion created when Congress, in multiple places in the Patient Protection and Affordable Health Care Act, included phrases such as “integrative health care” and “integrative practitioner” without defining what they mean. The IHPC’s approach is to broadly define who should be included in workforce planning, rather than to specifically define an integrative practitioner. 

Comment: The significant short-coming in the IHPC statement is that it does not note any specific traits that distinguish an “integrative practitioner” from one who is not an integrative practitioner. This is a significant problem. How can IHPC or anyone else argue for the need for inclusion of “integrative practitioners” if Congress does not have a handle on what the term means. The American Association of Naturopathic Physicians, a recent member of the IHPC’s Partners in Health program, offers such a definition in their response to the National Prevention Strategy. IHPC is the ideal body to do this. I hope they still plan to tackle it.  

Image

Gaudet: Key position at the VA

Veterans Administration names Tracy Gaudet, MD to head new Office
of Patient Centered Care and Cultural Transformation

On January 19, 2011, the
Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) announced that it is creating a new office to develop
personal, patient-centered models of care for Veterans. The release notes that Tracy Williams Gaudet, MD will direct the new Office
of Patient Centered Care and Cultural Transformation
. Gaudet formerly served in two key academic medicine capacities in integrative medicine: as executive director
of Duke Integrative Medicine and prior to that as the first director of the then “Program in Integrative Medicine” established by Andrew Weil, MD at the University of Arizona.
The VA model that Gaudet is developing is expected to influence care in the over 1,000 “points of care across” the
Nation that are operated by the VA. States Gaudet:
“The Office
of Patient Centered Care and Cultural Transformation will be a living,
learning organization in which we will discover and demonstrate new
models of care, analyze the results, and then create strategies that
allow for their translation and implementation across the VA.  VA will
continue to be a national leader in innovation, and, in this way, we
will provide the future of high-quality health care to our Veterans.” An integrative leader familiar with military practices stated about Gaudet’s appointment:
“An unusual pick, but a good one.”

Image

Vet’s Administration: Openness to integrative practices

Comment: This is a huge sign of the uptake of integrative approaches in the nation’s largest healthcare system. I couldn’t help but notice that the release stated that Gaudet worked at “Duke Integrated Medicine” rather than its correct title of “Duke Integrative Medicine.”  May have been a slip up. Then again, the VA media managers may have chosen a term more comfortable to the mainstream and less revealing that would allow Gaudet to begin her work without being beset by integrative medicine’s antagonists. My guess: The integrative practice community will soon have a FOT group paralleling the informal FOB that surrounded another influential Beltway person a decade ago.

Image

Stargrove: Leadership role as interactions expert

Mitchell Stargrove, ND, LAc appointed to HRSA pharmacy program leadership; participation in community teams invited

Mitchell Stargrove, ND, LAc, author of the highly regarded Herb, Nutrient and Drug Interactions and chief medical officer of MedicineWorks, publishers of InteractionsGuide.com  recently sent information regarding the Patient Safety and Clinical Pharmacy
Services Collaborative
(PSPC), sponsored by the Health Resources and Services
Administration (HRSA). Stargrove has been appointed as a member of the national Leadership Coordinating Council for the initiative. HRSA is inviting other practitioners organizations of various stripes to participate in PSPC community networks. HRSA describes PSPC as:

 ” … a breakthrough effort to improve the quality of
health care across America by integrating evidence-based clinical pharmacy
services into the care and management of high-risk, high-cost, complex
patients …
PSPC uses a fast-paced, iterative improvement method designed to
support teams in testing and spreading leading practices found to significantly
improve health outcomes and patient safety through the integration of clinical
pharmacy services. Key to the method’s effectiveness is that the leading
practices are drawn from real practice in organizations that have achieved outstanding
results.

The PSPC works through 128 teams in 43 states representing “community-based health care
providers, including health centers, Ryan White HIV/AIDS providers,
poison control centers and rural health clinics.” According to Stargrove, PSPC welcomes participation from diverse community organizations.
He
adds that recently the “Patient Safety and Clinical Pharmacy Services Alliance”
was incorporated as a non-profit organization “to serve as the vehicle for a
public-private partnership supporting the ongoing work of the PSPC
collaborative.”


 

Academics & Education

Image

Declares top priorities

Council of Colleges of Acupuncture and
Oriental Medicine (CCAOM) announces
goals shaping their strategic plan

The Council of Colleges of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine has 55 member schools representing some 8,000 students who are seeking to enter the workforce as licensed acupuncturists. The Winter 2010 CCAOM newsletter lists the following priorities in its present strategic plan.


1. Promote
AOM as a viable profession
and healthcare option

2. Enhance
graduate financial and professional success

3. Provide
leadership on issues that impact member institutions

4. Promote
the effective use of technology

5. Enhance
faculty development and student learning

Comment: Pleasing to see #2 prioritized highly with #1. Executives in academia disagree about whether or not an educational institution needs to take responsibility for the state of the profession(s) into which they graduate students. My view is that the schools must be involved, especially if they are educating students for an emerging field, whether licensed acupuncturists or of integrative medical doctors, in which much participation is speculative. My position is part principle and part based on the realities that schools are the main aggregators of capital in these fields. The budgets of the professional associations pale.

Image

NYCC President Frank Nicchi, DC, MS: Integration agenda

NYCC promotes “integration” to attract students

New York Chiropractic College is using integration as a calling card for new students. In a website listing of reasons for why to choose NYCC, just after the standard “Academic Excellence,” web-surfing prospective enrollees will see “Integration.” Clicking on the word brings them to a special page that states that students at NYCC, which also has boasts a School of Applied Clinical Nutrition and the Finger Lakes School of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine, will:

  • “Gain
    the opportunity to work in collaborative settings with providers of
    mainstream medical therapies and scientifically supported alternative
    therapies
  • “Benefit
    from a holistic educational approach with shared emphases on the science,
    art and philosophy of chiropractic and Oriental medicine
  • “Experience
    integrated internship opportunities including NYCC’s own health centers,
    nationally renowned hospitals, Department of Defense sites and
    free-standing ambulatory care centers
  • “Discover
    our teamwork approach to integration – to create integral care,
    cooperation is needed between physicians, chiropractors, acupuncturists,
    massage therapists, and other practitioners
  • “Learn
    the knowledge and specialized skills to be part of a holistic circle of
    care, and modalities dedicated to the total wellness of patients.”

Comment:  I came across this page while working on a separate project. It occurred to me that anyone seeking to convince a stuck colleague that s/he can’t rightfully characterize the chiropractic profession as wanting to go it alone and in opposition to conventional medicine ought to be handed this statement of value from NYCC. While there remain holier-than-thou antagonists in some leadership positions in chiropractic academics and policy, what NYCC expresses here, and more importantly, increasingly practices, is an emerging strain. It’s ironic that the bull-headed, go-it-alone political power that earned chiropractic physicians a place in the VA and DoD has now created the opportunity for new students to be “part of a holistic circle of care.” Good for NYCC.


Image

Seeks candidates for presidency

Boucher Institute for Naturopathic Medicine seeks new prdsident

The Boucher Institute of Naturopathic Medicine (BINM), Western Canada’s one accredited naturopathic medical school, is seeking a new president. BINM accepts a maximum of 36 students per new enrollment and currently employs 42 faculty members and 34 support staff. The job description notes responsibility for “overall leadership, management and direction of BINM” together with the ability to “create a conscious, caring, learning community consistent with the principles of naturopathic medicine.” while also “lead(ing) by example to encourage personal growth, individual responsibility, collaboration, holistic living and contemplative education.” The posting points toward an individual training as a naturopathic physician but does not require it. More information is available through

boardchair@binm.org.

Philanthropy

Image

Forming CAM group

Grantmakers in Health to establish “Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM)
Funders’ Network”

On February 1, 2011 members of Grantmakers in Health sent an email their members to announce the
launch of the Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) Funders’ Network. The email stated that:

“The purpose of this network is to: increase information exchange, support
knowledge, allow grantmakers to build constructive relationships with other
funders, and facilitate peer learning by allowing participants to hear what
other funders have to say about opportunities, challenges, and potential
partners in the field of complementary and alternative medicine …

This face-to-face meeting will allow us to think
strategically about what philanthropy’s role can and should be in shaping a
future healthcare delivery system that integrates complementary and alternative
medicine into conventional care settings.”

All recipients were “invited to attend the inaugural meeting of the
Network at GIH’s upcoming Annual Meeting on Health Philanthropy.” The meeting will be Friday, March 4, 2011.
The CAM Funders Network is supported by funding from
the W. K. Kellogg Foundation, the Fannie E. Rippel Foundation, and the Samueli
Foundation.

Comment:  This is a smart development and a great constituency in which to create visibility for “CAM” and integrative medicine, which still typically need a kick-start from philanthropy to get moving inside the mainstream delivery system. (See article on U Arizona Fellows in this Round-up.) This initiative is distinct, in my view, from the Bravewell Collaborative of philanthropists. The Bravewell has, from shortly after its founding a decade ago as the Philanthropic Collaborative for Integrative Medicine, aggregated donors to back a few specific, strategic initiatives. Credit the 3 foundations that have taken the lead in organizing the meeting.

Image

Largest grant ever to ND school

National College of Natural Medicine receives $1.35-million gift from owners of Bob’s Red Mill Natural Foods


The National College of Natural Medicine in Portland, Oregon announced on January 31, 2011 a
$1.35 million gift from
Bob and Charlee Moore, founders of Bob’s Red Mill Natural Foods. The Moore
family gift, the largest in NCNM’s 55 years, will fund NCNM’s
Ending Childhood Obesity (ECO) Project and also help establish a research and teaching kitchen on NCNM’s campus. According to the release, the ECO Project is a free,
community-based nutrition program that “aims to reduce chronic disease and
morbidity associated with childhood obesity by promoting healthy food choices
and empowering families through education and training.”
Moore explained the gift: “We want to do more to inspire people to make changes in their diets-and
we believe that our growing partnership with NCNM will accomplish that.”
NCNM student clinicians presently delivery care in a wide network of community health clinical programs.

Image

Donors Bob and Charlee Moore

NCNM
President, David J. Schleich, PhD noted that nutrition “is the cornerstone to good health, and the foundation of the medical
education that we provide.” Naturopathic physicians have the highest level of clinical nutrition training of any physician-level practitioners. The ECO Project was developed by NCNM’s Courtney Jackson,
ND
, an adjunct faculty member who is the lead physician overseeing the new ECO
team.
For NCNM, the gift marks the launch of the school’s $25-million capital campaign. Bob’s Red Mill Natural Foods is described in the release as “a distinctive
stone grinding miller of whole grains, founded in 1978 with the mission of
moving people back to the basics with healthy whole grains, high-fiber and
complex carbohydrates.”

Image

NCNM President David Schleich, PhD

Comment: One of the challenges for the licensed “CAM” fields is that few foundations, family funds, individual philanthropists or major corporations choose to bestow major gifts on their educational, clinical and research or community programs like the ECO Project funded here. Few government grants for education are open and in fact, very few NIH NCCAM dollars, relatively speaking, go to these “CAM” schools. All donors and granters favor conventional institutions and academic health centers. I can only think of 2 prior donations of over $1-million to naturopathic medical institutions.  The maturation of the fields, scores of good ideas, and access to integrative services are each held back. The generosity of Bob and Charlee Moore must be appreciated in this context. As one who sometimes looks for such dollars to bridge this healthcare education disparity, here’s hope that this is the beginning of a trend! Congratulations NCNM, and to the many individuals and families who stand to benefit from the ECO project.


Professions & Organizations

Image

Hawk: Health and wellness-focused PBRN

Health & wellness-focused chiropractic practice-based research network (PBRN) founded

A new chiropractic practice-based research network (PBRN) has been established to “address research questions that require a real-world setting to be
answered.” The
Integrated Chiropractic Outcomes Network (ICON) was created by Cheryl Hawk, DC, PhD and others specifically with a focus on examining health and wellness outcomes of chiropractic treatment. The mission: “Conduct
collaborative research through a partnership between researchers and
practitioners with the ultimate goal of enhancing the health of the
public and contributing to the scientific evidence base related to
health promotion and disease prevention.” The headline of the solicitation to chiropractors to join the network is ICON’s planned focus on wellness.” This is in contradistinction to the
“chiropractic research, to date, [that] has focused more on pain and symptom
management than on prevention and health promotion, even though
chiropractic has traditionally considered itself to be
prevention-oriented.” ICON is using a forum in ChiroACCESS to get rolling.”

Comment:  This is a timely development, particularly given the elevated interest of NIH NCCAM in the real world, and a nascent but apparently significant interest in health and wellness outcomes. My only concern is for Hawk, who seems to have started up a dozen useful projects and relationships in the last year, for which she was honored in the Integrator Top 10 People for 2010. Hawk appears to be making the argument for human cloning.

Image

Upton: Lists organization’s impacts

Impacts of the American Herbal Pharmaciopoeia recounted by exec Roy Upton

Roy Upton, RH, DAy, executive director and founder of the American Herbal Pharmacopoeia (AHP), recently reported to his board a list of impacts AHP “has had on the botanical world worldwide.” AHP was formed in 1995 “to promote the responsible use of herbal products and herbal medicines.” Upton shared this overview of the organization’s recent contributions:
 

  • “Canada: When the Natural Health Product Directorate
    was formed in Canada, some of the consultants to Health Canada brought our St.
    John’s wort monograph to the regulators as an example of what was needed in
    Canada. This led to the adoption of the monograph system that they now have in
    place. They likely would have come to that conclusion without AHP but it
    greased the wheels and was a no-brainer. Canada formally acknowledges the
    authoritativeness of AHP monographs and recently entered into a collaboration
    to develop a bacopa monograph.


  • “Hong Kong:
    After the publication of [AHP’s] Schisandra
    and Reishi monographs, two researchers from Hong Kong’s Baptist University came
    up to me at a conference there and excitedly told me they had proposed and it
    was adopted to develop a similar set of monographs for Chinese herbs in Hong
    Kong. This gave birth to the Hong Kong standards, now a corner stone
    of TCM quality assurance.


  • “Africa and South America:
    AHP was partly responsible
    for inspiring the development of the South American and African Herbal
    Pharmacopoeias, the latter of which was just published. At USP, their
    researchers told me that whenever they are going to do a botanical monograph
    they first look to see if AHP has done one and then takes their lead from
    that.



  • “US Pharmascopoeia:

    AHP’s monograph format was also almost
    completely emulated by USP in their recently published Dietary Supplement
    Compendium. [Upton was a member of the committee that did this.]



  • “HPLTC and Microscopy:

    Eike Reich of Camag, the
    world’s leader in HPTLC [High Performance Thin Layer Chromatography] equipment, used AHP’s focus on HPTLC and inclusion of
    HPTLC images as a spring-board to show USP, the European Pharmacopoeia, Indian
    Pharmacopoeia, and Chinese Pharmacopeia how valuable it is to have the images.
    As of that time, none of them provided images. Now they are all developing
    compendia to present the images. And, HPTLC, which prior to AHP’s work was
    relegated to the doldrums of analytical technologies in the botanical world, has
    become a fully integrated component of the QC programs of many companies. We
    have pushed the community on microscopy as well with USP seeing our work and
    developing their own micro images in the Compendium.”

Comment: This is quite a track record for an under-funded organization braced significantly by the labors of Upton and his team.

Image

Gawande: Health coaches in key cost-cutting role

Health coaches get boost from Atul Gawande’s recent New Yorker piece

Comment: The writings of Atul Gawande, MD on the state of the US healthcare system have had a particularly significant influence on policy makers since Barack Obama singled out his June 2009 New Yorker article on the shocking variations in Medicare payments in McAllen, Texas compared to other parts of the country. Gawande’s January 17, 2011 New Yorker article, The Hot Spotters: Can we lower costs by giving the neediest patients better care, is stimulating a similarly high level of interest. One beneficiary will certainly be health coaches and health coaching. In examining how one medical group works with its most expensive an demanding clientele, Gawande reports that a central strategy is the employment of a small battalion of health coaches. This visibility for health coaches gives added urgency to the initiative led by Harvard’s Margaret Moore, RN and University of Minnesota’s Karen Lawson, MD to set standards of education and credentialing for this emerging field. That initiative, reported here, is presently developing a white paper that is expected to be completed by April 1, 2011. 

Miscellaneous

Image

Re-examining CAM coverage

Swiss government reverses itself gives CAM “chance to prove its worth as insurable”

The January 14, 2011 posting is entitled Swiss government has given complementary medicine a second chance to prove its worth as an insurable health cost.
Five therapies
previously struck from the Swiss state insurance list will be reimbursable from
2012 as part of a six-year trial period.” Then reads the article: “The sting: all must prove
their ‘efficacy, cost-effectiveness and suitability’ by 2017.” Targeted are p
roviders
of homeopathy, holistic, herbal and neural therapies and traditional
Chinese medicine. They will first have toi show evidence of effectiveness then havev their results “
go before a recognised international institute – still to be
determined – that will provide an independent scientific assessment.” NIH NCCAM
is among those mentioned. The therapies have had quite a ride:

  • In 2005, the Swiss interior ministry banned the therapies.
  • In 2009, 2/3 of the Swiss population voted to have them on the list of paid services.
  • In December 2010, a Swiss federal commission recommended thatthey be banned permanently.


Comment
:  … and now the present development. Perhaps this should go to the Hague. CAM Faces International Tribunal. And will the Swiss brief on the 2009 referendum is here. Thanks to reader Mathias Kaesabier, executive vice-president for ABC Coding Solutions for the heads up.

Image

Wheedon: Huge Medicare-chiro pilot examined

Health services researcher James Wheedon, DC explores whether Illinois outcomes biased chiropractic-Medicare study

Dartmouth health services research James Wheedon has published a follow-up analysis of the controversial Medicare-expanded chiropractic pilot in Topics in Integrative Health Care as Did Inclusion of Illinois Bias the Medicare Chiropractic Services Demonstration? Wheedon concludes: “An
association between chiropractic costs and all costs in Illinois (not
observed in other sites) may have confounded the reported effect of the
demonstration in Illinois.”
  The original release of the demonstration project data was covered in the Integrator in January 2010 as Medicare Pilot Shakes Out as $50-Million High Stakes Game for Chiropractors

Image

D’Adamo: Spring Generative Medicine symposium

Institute for Human Individuality (IfHI) Biannual Symposium:
Generative Medicine, May 20-22, 2011
 

This
weekend intensive seminar frm the Institute for Human Individuality (IfHI) Biannual Symposium
features naturopathic physician, scientist, lecturer
and author, Peter J. D’Adamo, ND. According to a note from the Institute, attendees will be presented with “the
most current research findings in polymorphic medicine, epigenetics and
nutrigenomics.” D’Adamo will be joined by special guest lecturer,
Dr. Mitch Bebel Stargrove.
(Note: Stargrove’s appointment to the leadership of a Health Resources Services Administration project is noted under policy in this Round-up.) Dolce Conference Center, Norwalk, Connecticut.

Image

Homeopath Ullman: Focus on Nobel winner stirs debate

Homeopathy spokesperson Dana Ullman, MPH stirs up Huffington Post audience with piece on Nobel-winning virologist

Author, homeopath and frequent Huffington Post blogger Dana Ullman, MPH, struck a rich chord with his January 30, 2011 post entitled, “Luc Montagnier, Nobel prize winner, takes homeopathy seriously.” Ullman begins noting Montagnier’s 2008 Nobel Prize in
2008 for discovering the AIDS virus then turns to a December 24, 2010 interview with Montagnier in Science magazine. There, Montagnier not only supports the field but also backs the ideas in homeopathy that are most ridiculed: “I can’t say that homeopathy is right in everything. What I can say now
is that the high dilutions (used in homeopathy) are right. High
dilutions of something are not nothing. They are water structures which
mimic the original molecules.” Within 3 days, Ullman’s article had generated over 900 comments. Over 9000 readers had shared the article with others.

Image

Manahan: View of health reform re-published

Bill Manahan, MD featured in Minnesota Medicine 

A commentary from Bill Manahan, MD, originally published in the Integrator in slightly different format, has been published in Minnesota Medicine, the journal of the Minnesota Medical Association. The piece is entitled Eight Suggestions for Promoting Physician Well-Being:
Ways to make medicine more satisfying for doctors and better for their health
. Manahan, an Integrator adviser, originally wrote the piece in response to a call for ideas for #10 in the Top 10
for 2008. He responded with his own Top 10 list, in his case, of reform ideas. Manahan’s views were posted as Holistic Leader Bill Manahan, MD: “My Tenth Idea – Revisioning Healthcare for 2009.

Comment: A few months after Manahan graciously contacted me for approval for re-publication (the Integrator has a liveral re-publication policy, in line with its mission), he sent along the link, with this note: “This is the article that came about because an
editor at Minnesota Medicine was reading your Blog and she came across my
article.” Ahh … the power and influence!


Image

La Lanne: Fitness pioneer dies

Jack LaLanne: 1914-2011

The appropriate metaphor for showman and bodybuilder Jack LaLanne’s role in the fitness, wellness and integrative health movement is more pillar than roots. The “godfather of fitness” as he was known by many (and as is advertised on his site) died January 23rd at 96. In a “Meet Jack” video on his site from what looks like 50 years ago, La Lanne coaches his early television audience with:

 ” … you know, there has been so much talk of late of the importance of exercise, the importance of fitness, the importance of positive thinking .. I don’t like to call it exercise, I like to call it trim-nastics.” 

LaLanne was a graduate of the Oakland Chiropractic College. A note honoring his promotion of chiropractic, in an era of horrendous polarization, was published by the Foundation for Chiropractic progress, which is, suitably, the marketing organization for that profession.

Send your comments to
johnweeks@theintegratorblog.com

for inclusion in a future Your Comments Forum.
]]>
5862
Integrative Medicine and Integrated Health Care Round-up: October 2010 https://healthy.net/2010/10/08/integrative-medicine-and-integrated-health-care-round-up-october-2010/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=integrative-medicine-and-integrated-health-care-round-up-october-2010 Fri, 08 Oct 2010 17:19:24 +0000 https://healthy.net/2010/10/08/integrative-medicine-and-integrated-health-care-round-up-october-2010/ Summary: IHPC, others convene stakeholders for policy action plan on integrative practices in reform law … Goertz named to influential Board of Governors of PCORI, significant new, national comparative effectiveness research institute … AANP urges members to weigh in on endocrine disruption bill … Australian study reports cost savings from acupuncture and 3 natural products … Disturbing national data on incomes of licensed AOM practitioners stimulates soul-searching … Two-thirds of massage therapists note downturn in practices in lagging economy … Supplement sales hold steady … Managed CAM and wellness firm American Specialty Health hits $147-million in revenues … Penny George Institute/Allina publish 2010 outcomes report … Donna Karan’s Urban Zen expands nationally with Kent State partnership in program for nurses … Georgetown and Bastyr initiate novel agreement between naturopathic and conventional academic programs … Marino Center links with Mass Medical Society for integrative medicine training … True North Healing Center’s Dahlborg brings integrative business model to Dartmouth Medical School … Alliance for Natural Health examines Wikipedia biases against natural health and medical alternatives … Foundation for Chiropractic Progress a useful model for fund-raising a discipline’s national initiative … AAAOM breaks pattern in naming medical doctor Niemtzow to board … Riley and editorial team resign from Alternative Therapies in Health and Medicine citing differences with new owners … Publication opportunities in new peer-reviewed Topics in Integrative Health Care/Hawk and in special integrative health issue of Patient Education Counseling/Rakel … 2011 Integrative Health Care Symposium to be held in New York, March 4-6 … Horace Elliott, Ad Haramati and Sherman Cohn honored …

Policy

“Stakeholder Conference on Integrated Health Care Reform” develops policy action plan: IHPC, Palmer, TIIH lead effort

The Patient Protection and Affordable Health Care Act (PPACA), a.k.a. the Obama-Pelosi health reform law, included historic new recognition of complementary and integrative practices and practitioners in multiple sections of the law. Astute politicos will know that language in a law is an empty shell. Work must focus on the regulations that will determine what the law means, and populating relevant advisory committees with professionals who understand and can advocate for integrative practice concepts and approaches.

On September 27-29, 2010, a multi-disciplinary and multi-stakeholder group of integrative practice leaders convened in Washington, DC at the Georgetown University Conference Center to formulate a coordinated response to the work ahead. The lead organizing agency was the Integrated Healthcare Policy Consortium (IHPC), led by executive director Janet Kahn, PhD. IHPC was joined by Palmer College of Chiropractic, represented by Kahn’s co-lead and fellow IHPC board member, Christine Goertz, DC, PhD and The Institute for Integrative Health, led by Brian Berman, MD. In morning sessions, participants heard from congressional aides and lobbyists close to the development of the law. Participants then met in working groups in the following interest areas, with the relevant section of PPACA noted: access and non-discrimination (2706); healthcare work force (5101); prevention and wellness (4001); CPT codes; comparative effectiveness research (6301); and integration in practice (3502). Each team recommended national action priorities.

IHPC plans to develop these into a report on the meeting that will be broadly disseminated (and will be reported here). Kahn noted that the organization also plans to post content from the presentations on their website. (Check http://www.ihpc.info as these may come available at any time.) A running theme was how to create the best coalition, and resources, to build the active lobbying presence in Washington, D.C. to move the agenda once articulated.

Comment: This conference was remarkable evidence of the spirit of trust and collaboration that has evolved over the last decade through multiple meetings and relationships among the influential MDs, DCs, nurses, researchers, NDs, massage therapists, acupuncture and Oriental medicine professionals and other stakeholders invited to this conference. I will be reporting sections of the content in the future as I await IHPC’s report which promises to be something of a blue print for action in the months and years ahead.

A clear message from presenter and participant Deborah Senn, former Washington State Insurance Commissioner: Without vigilance, the new law will be hollow. So to all of us with skin in this game: 1) donate to support the lobbying; 2) get your organizations to expand IHPC’s band-width by becoming members of the organization’s Partners for Health; and 3) think about what very wealthy individuals are out there with a joint love of policy and “alternative medicine” or integrative health. This is a time when such an individual or individuals can have tremendous impact. Credit the 3 lead organizations for pulling this meeting together on a tight time frame, and Bastyr University and Standard Homeopathic, Co. for their sponsorship grants.

Integrative practice researcher Goertz named to influential Board of Governors of the $650-million/year Patient Centered Outcomes Research Institute

A September 23, 2010 release from the General Accounting Office announced the 19 members of the powerful Board of Governors of the new Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute (PCORI) established under PPACA, the health reform act. PCORI was created, like the Institute of Medicine, as an independent nonprofit corporation that is not “an agency or establishment of the U.S. Government.” Christine Goertz, DC, PhD, vice chancellor for research and health policy at Palmer College of Chiropractic was among those named. A release from Palmer College notes that “Goertz’ experience and expertise is in the area of integrative healthcare research.” Goertz has held prior positions as deputy director of the Samueli Institute and as the first program officer on health services research for the NIH National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine.

The purpose of PCORI is “to assist patients, clinicians, purchasers, and policy-makers in making informed health decisions by advancing the quality and relevance of evidence” regarding the prevention, treatment, diagnosis and management of diseases and health conditions in various patient populations, then disseminating these patient-centered, outcomes-based research findings. The Institute’s budget will climb to $650-million in 2014, where it will remain through 2019.

Comment: Goertz, an Integrator adviser, is well-connected throughout the integrative health community. She was elected recently to the board of directors of the Integrated Healthcare Policy Consortium and was instrumental in driving the stakeholders’ meeting noted in this Round-up. Goertz was also the founding co-chair of the Research Working Group of the Academic Consortium for Complementary and Alternative Health Care and a program committee member for the 2009 research conference of the Consortium of Academic Health Centers for Integrative Medicine. As far back as 2001, Goertz was a participant in the Integrative Medicine Industry Leadership Summit. Goertz is also, according to a release on the appointment from the American Chiropractic Association, an “active ACA member” who “serves as chair of the association’s Performance Measures Work Group, is a member of its Health Promotion and Wellness Committee and consults on research issues.”

While many in the field hoped that more than one individual who is known to be knowledgeable about integrative practice had been appointed to PCORI’s governing board, the consensus is that Goertz’ selection is terrific. Thanks to Palmer Chancellor Dennis Marchiori, DC, PhD for supporting Goertz in a position that is certain to have many demands and which will pull her away from her hands-on duties at Palmer. Marchiori spoke for many in the Palmer release: “I can think of no one better than Dr. Christine Goertz to play a key role in this new national initiative to set the agenda for patient-centered research, and help direct U.S. efforts in this area.”

Naturopathic association urges members to action on Endocrine Disruption Prevention Act (S 2828, HR 4190)

In an action push in September, the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians (AANP) urged its members to contact their members of Congress in support of the Endocrine Disruption Prevention Act (S2828 and HR4190). According to the AANP, the bills would authorize the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences “to conduct endocrine disruption research in order to develop assays that will identify endocrine disrupting chemicals and determine their safety. The program will rely on a panel of scientific experts, free of conflict of interest, to evaluate the findings and determine the level of concern.” Such information will be passed on to relevant regulatory agencies to propose appropriate responsive action.

Comment: Nice to see the AANP act outside of its particular guild interest to promote this critical public health issue. Environmental issues are close to naturopathic thinking relative to the role of terrain in disease and health. The AANP action is another expression of the number of overt connections between the integrative practice fields and integrative health that were explored here. Credit executive director Karen Howard and board member Michael Cronin, ND for moving this.

Cost & Economics

Australian report finds cost benefits from acupuncture and natural product interventions

The National Institute of Complementary Medicine (NICM), established with seed funding provided by the Australian Government and a New South Wales governmental agency has published a recent report that found cost effectiveness for most of the handful of therapies examined. The agency sent a September 13, 2010 press release entitled Economic report finds complementary medicine could ease health budget.

Modality/agent
Finding
Acupuncture for chronic low back pain Cost effective if used as a complement to standard care (medication, physiotherapy, exercises, education), although not generally cost effective when used as a replacement to standard care (unless co‐morbidity of depression is included).
St. John’s Wort Determined to be cost effective compared  to standard anti depressants for patients with mild to moderate (not severe) depression. The main driver is the lower unit cost of St. John’s wort.
Fish oils rich in omega‐3 fatty acids Highly cost effective when used as an adjunctive treatment in people with a history of coronary heart disease, achieving reduced death and morbidity. Not cost effective in reducing non-steroidal anti‐inflammatory drug use in rheumatoid arthritis.
 Phytodolor (proprietary herbal) Cost saving in managing osteoarthritis compared with the principal non steroidal anti-inflammatory drug Diclofenac.


The National Center is hosted by the University of Western Sydney. According to the report, “Australians spend over $3.5 billion each year on complementary medicines and therapies, most commonly to assist in the management of chronic disease and improve health and well-being.”

Comment via Integrator adviser Michael Levin: The link to this study was provided me by adviser Michael Levin (thank you Michael!). He subsequently pointed to this specific comment in the report: “The exclusion of productivity costs means that these results may be conservative. Chronic pain is associated with absenteeism from work and reduced

Double benefits from acupuncture?

“If the presenteeism and absenteeism costs of low-back pain are averted, the benefits from acupuncture would double.”

work effectiveness (presenteeism). Access Economics [the author of the report] estimated that in 2007 while the health system costs of chronic pain accounted for 20% of the total costs, the burden of disease and productivity losses associated with chronic pain each accounted for 43% of the total cost. If the presenteeism and absenteeism costs of LBP are averted in a one to one ratio with the burden of disease as Access Economics (2007) would suggest, the benefits from acupuncture would double (or more than double if the other indirect financial costs such as informal carer costs were also
included).”

Additional Comment: It is noteworthy that the conclusion of the Australian government on St. John’s Wort is that the use of the herb is cost-effective while that of the U.S. government, via NCCAM research on the herb, is that it is no more effective than a placebo. It is also noteworthy that including the concept of presenteeism in cost studies, see Levin’s comment, as was done in this positive Canada Post-naturopathic doctors trial, remains very rare.

NCCAOM survey finds stark challenges for most graduates of acupuncture and Oriental medicine schools

The 2008 Job Task Analysis by the National Certification Commission for Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine (NCCAOM) included a set of questions on income, education debt and practice settings. The questions were added to fill gaps in the profession’s self-knowledge. A key finding: 70% of respondents gross <$60,000 a year with significant percentages grossing less than $40,000. Meantime, median student loan debt has grown to $56,000. Publication of the findings has kicked off a round of sometimes acrimonious soul-searching in the profession. Lisa Rohleder, LAc, co-founder of the Community Acupuncture Network (CAN), captured the sentiment by reference to a well known children’s book about a boy named Alexander and called the findings “the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Numbers.” NCCAOM CEO Kory Ward-Cook, PhD, CAE, is quoted in this Integrator article on the subject, which includes a chart of key outcomes:

“I agree with [Rohleder’s] analysis. It’s sad (that practitioners are making so little). This is the first time this information is coming out. A lot of organizations aren’t going to like it. It’s lower than they have been saying …There appear to be schools where students thrive, and some where they don’t … We need to address the problem. Maybe we don’t need to graduate so many. Maybe we need to figure out how to employ them. We’ve got to figure out if the profession will be a two-tier system or non-tier, whether it will be doctoral level or non-doctoral or both. We have to figure this out.”

Rohleder, who has over the last 4 years engaged the profession in a discussion about its economic viability and its ability to reach patients, offers a pithy summation: “Acupuncture education, and the conventional acupuncture business model, ought to come with a warning label, the way cigarettes do: NOT SUSTAINABLE. May take years of your life and leave you with nothing, except huge student loans.”

Comment: I view these data as a call to action. NCCAOM’s findings that graduates felt ill-prepared both on business issues and on collaborating with others is a starting place. Addressing business issues needs to be a major national campaign. Graduate them and they will come doesn’t appear to be working.

Massage Today poll finds 2/3 of therapists seeing decline in clientele amidst economic sluggishness

An online poll from Massage Today is finding that a steady 63%-65% of respondents responded “Yes” when asked: “During this economic climate, have you experienced a reduction in your number of clients?”  Over a fifth (21%) report an increase and the remaining 16% experience their business as more or less unchanged. As of October 5, 2010, 563 individuals had responded to the online poll that was published with the October 2010 edition of the online magazine from MPA Media. A discussion among members of the massage field is available at this Facebook page. The Massage Today poll ran with an article entitled: “Tough Times, Don’t Panic: Use your downtime to build your business.”

Survey finds supplement sales strong despite, or because of, economic downturn

A survey by an independent polling firm contracted by the Council for Responsible Nutrition (CRN) provoked a press release announcing that Retailers see strong supplement sales as consumer confidence holds steady. 66% of adults “label themselves as supplement users”, up from 65% last year and in the same ballpark since 2005. Those classifying themselves as “regular users” also remained even. One supplement singled out as seeing strong growth in sales is Vitamin D. The growth ids associated with emerging science. Others “reported as steady and growing are probiotics, fish and flaxseed oil, calcium and multiple vitamins.” The article quotes a leader of a retailers’ trade association sharing that at a recent conference “everyone
was speaking of their uptick in supplement sales …The economic effect
seems to be pushing consumers towards supplements to maintain their health, with the high cost of healthcare.”

Major CAM managed care firm American Specialty Health in new digs, reports $147-million in 2009 business

San Diego-based American Specialty Health Incorporated (ASH) announced in early October that the firm and its subsidiaries, including Healthyroads, will be vacating its 156,000 square feet of existing office space in downtown San Diego. The firm, founded by chairman George DeVries as a chiropractic managed care firm in 1987, is transitioning to complex in the Sorrento Mesa business district where ASH will inhabit two buildings: a 81,000 square-foot building to house Healthyroads and the rest of ASH operations a 107,000 square foot building. In the release, the firm noted that its revenues reached $147-million in 2009, up roughly 50% from a decade earlier.

Hospital Integration

Penny George Institute-Allina publish web-available 2010 report on outcomes of inpatient integrative care

Those wanting a look inside the philosophy, practice, outcomes and educational initiatives of the nation’s largest hospital-based integrative health care operation will be quick to examine the 32-page pdf Overview and Outcomes Report 2010 from the Penny George Institute. Each month, staff provides “enhanced care” through 900 inpatient visits and 700 outpatient visits at Abbott Northwestern Hospital, the largest in the Allina Hospitals & Clinics system. Integrative care services offered by the operation’s 15 credentialed providers are listed. Page 15 begins a synopsis of research projects under way and completed at the Institute, which as part of its mission to be a pilot project for the nation is documenting and sharing its experience. New outcomes of a resilience training on depression among hospital employees are reported, showing benefits across depression, functionality and presenteeism indicators. The support of system medical doctors of the operation, led by Lori Knutson, RN, BS-HN, has grown continuously as they have observed the experience of the benefits to
patients. Abbott is also high on the project, if the giving of its foundation is any
indication. The Institute received a $1.9-million grant from Abbott’s charitable arm  in 2009.

Education

RW Johnson grant supports Kent State University adoption of Urban Zen self-care curriculum for nurses

A notice in the October 2010 issue of the e-news from Urban Zen (UZ), announces that Urban Zen’s “special curriculum of self-care for nurses” is presently being taught at Kent State University. Urban Zen is the Donna Karan-backed initiative that includes the Urban Zen Integrative Therapy (UZIT) program. The Kent State program is one of the largest nursing programs in the country. The
inclusion of the program was made possible through a grant from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.
The note in the UZ newsletter adds that the development “was made possible by an Urban Zen
friend and supporter” who was not named. UZIT anticipates that the Kent
State University program will be “the first of many nursing and medical
schools that incorporate the UZIT curriculum into the traditional
healthcare training to allow doctors and nurses to learn and incorporate
self-care into their professional practice and their personal
well-being.” In her introductory note in the bulletin, Karan writes: “I
am so very proud to share with you that my dream to have Urban Zen
Integrative Therapists across the country is coming true.”

Comment: “Self-care and meditation coming/We’re finally caring for ourselves/This summer I heard my inner voice/More healing in Ohio/More healing in Ohio.” Apologies, Neil.

Georgetown University and Bastyr University linked in inter-disciplinary, inter-institutional relationship

A model inter-institutional relationship may help bridge the chasm that separates health professions education in conventional academic health centers from institutions educating students for the distinctly licensed integrative practice (“CAM”) professions. Says one leader: “I believe we are poised to make an important advance in how the future training of health professionals may evolve.” The speaker is Adi Haramati, PhD, integrative medicine leader at Georgetown University, describing a new relationship between Georgetown and Bastyr University relative to Bastyr’s naturopathic medical program and Georgetown’s MS CAM program. Haramati and his co director Hakima Amri, PhD are exploring similar relationships with chiropractic schools and other health professions institutions. Bastyr’s vice president and provost Tim Callahan, PhD led the relationship development inside Bastyr. The developers “would like nothing more” than to see this bridge-building relationship be used as a model for other academic health centers and CAM institutions. The exchange is described in more detail in this Integrator article.

Marino Center and Massachusetts Medical Society combine for October 28 integrative medicine conference

Anne McCaffrey, MD, medical director of the Marino Center, a large integrative clinic in the Boston area, to announce the October 28th program entitled Integrative Medicine 101: Practical Approaches to Integrative Medicine for Primary Care Providers that Marino is producing. The session is sponsored by the Massachusetts Medical Society. McCaffrey says the target audience is primary care providers “who are naive to Integrative Medicine/CAM therapies, rather than an in-depth conference in any specific area.” The 2009 iteration was “a sold out show and got very good evaluations from the majority of our attendees.”

Comment: This news piece, and that below, are remarkable evidence on the in-migration of integrative thinking into conventional environments.

Integrative medicine center True North teaches its distinct business model to Maine Dartmouth Family Medicine program

“A new paradigm of practice management in an integrative setting.” This is the framing in a September 27, 2010 press release from the True North Health Center regarding a talk the clinic’s executive director, Tom Dahlborg, gave to 3rd year residents at the Maine Dartmouth Family Medicine program. The clinic has offered clinical rotations to residents in recent years. This was the first venture into teaching the business side of integrative care. The concepts may be new. At True North, “practitioners have the flexibility of choosing their own schedules and how much time they spend with patients, and also contribute to organization-wide decision-making, research studies, and collaborative case presentations.” Dahlborg, who has 21 years of healthcare administration experience including 5 as True North’s director, reportedly “emphasized the importance of not only working alongside practitioners who have training in other modalities, but truly collaborating with one another.” The model Dahlborg shared includes “integrated charts, collaborative development of patient care plans, participation in monthly circle case presentations, and appropriate in-house referrals.”

Maine Dartmouth Family Medicine Residency Program is one of eight Integrative Medicine in Residency (IMR) pilot sites associated with the Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine.

Comment: I confess to being a fan of mutual adoration societies, especially those that involve me. So having tracked the True North work of medical director and founder Bethany Hayes, MD, Dahlborg and others for a long while I was, as my father would have put it, tickled to receive one of their releases, on October 4, 2010, that featured the Integrator coverage of True North over time.

Organizations

Alliance for Natural Health takes on Wikipedia over biases against natural medicine

Integrator reader and sometimes contributor Tom Ballard, RN, ND pointed me to an article on the Alliance for Natural Health (ANH) website entitled Wikipedia’s Anti-Natural Health Slant. The article cites a half-dozen grievances that led to the conclusion that “the (Wikierdia) articles that are pro-health freedom or integrative medicine perspectives are consistently gutted, removed, or vandalized.” Examples are entries related to orthomolecular medicine, anti-aging medicine, the definition of nutritionist and a page describing Julian Whitaker, MD. The writer quotes Wikipedia co-founder, Larry Sanger, who has exited a relationship with the organization because, among other things, of “frequently unreliable content.” He clarifies: “In some fields and some topics, there are groups who ‘squat’ on articles and insist on making them reflect their own specific biases.” ANH recommends a separate site, Wiki4CAM, otherwise known as the Complementary and Alternative Medicine Encyclopedia.

Comment: Dana Ullman, MPH provides a look into one Wikipedia hotspot in this article: Where is Your Definition Tonight? Dana Ullman on the Virtual War in Wikipedia over Homeopathy

Image

Chiro organization models successful funding campaign

A model for fund-raising: Foundation 4 Chiropractic Progress reaches over 1500 regular contributors

Comment: The one profession associated with
integrative practice that has any significant financial clout is chiropractic, or chiropractic medicine, as some
put it. One leg upon which the discipline stands is the educational/promotional Foundation for Chiropractic Progress (F4CP).
The foundation’s focus is on creating visibility for the profession. The funders
include members of the profession (over 1500 have committed to regular
contributions), state associations, national organizations, educational
institutions and members of the industry. The organization’s September 2010 e-newsletter ticked off the visibility this has produced, namely, “pro
chiropractic advertisements in eight prominent newspapers and magazines – The
Wall Street Journal
, Working Mother, Sports Illustrated, Quad
City Times
, USA Today (Florida),
San Francisco Chronicle and the Pro Football Hall of Fame
Yearbook.”
The combined circulation: roughly 7-million.
The newsletter went on to honor new commitments and actions. Credit the work of Garrett Cuneo, F4CP executive

and past American Chiropractic Association executive and his powerful
board, for moving this agency. For those of you linked to other
professions with national agendas, whether or not it is the F4CP focus on marketing
and visibility, this organization models how to set up a base,
and the can-do ability to chip in collectively to make things happen.


Image

Niemtzow: First MD on AAAOM board

AAAOM breaks pattern, names leading medical acupuncturist Niemtzow to Board

In a September 17, 2010 notice to members entitled “
The AAAOM and the Middle Way,” the American Association of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine broke with a historic practice and named a medical acupuncturist, Richard Niemtzow, MD, to its board of directors. The AAAOM announcement sets this context:


“As you know, the mission of the AAAOM is to promote the
professional practice of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine to enhance the
public’s health and well being. In the evolving and increasingly complex
healthcare landscape, we strongly believe that respecting the diversity of the
broad AOM community through open dialog and sincere collaboration is required
for us to achieve this mission in the long term. We value diverse perspectives
while at the same time strive to find common ground that will help unify the
AOM profession and expand our role in healthcare in this country going forward.

The appointment of Niemtzow, the editor in chief of Medical Acupuncture,
the journal of the MD acupuncturist membership organization, is
positioned as “just one of many steps we will be taking to help create a
stronger and
more unified profession, advocating for the AOM community.” Then, more
context: “AAAOM believes in applying the principles of the ‘middle way,’
such as compassion, cooperation, coalition, and community–which
will serve all of us well as we go forward together. This represents the
balance we wish to create between our traditional roots and the
collaboration
we need in our contemporary professional landscape.”

Comment: I print the comments at length
as the new ground on which the AAAOM board is standing is still
new. The invocation suggest a felt need for the spirits of the grandfathers and grandmothers to
stabilize this foundation. The tensions in the field between those who would like to
own needles as a profession, and those, such as the AAAOM board, who
believe others have rights, is still strong. This is a great move.   

Publications Sept 27

Image

Riley: Differences with new ATHM ownership

Editor Riley and team resign from Alternative Therapies in Health and Medicine

In July 2010, Alternative Therapies in Health
and Medicine
, the first peer-review publication devoted to the field, was passed from Innovision Health Media into the hands of a new owner. On September 27, 2010, long-time integrative medicine leader (and perhaps the person who first dubbed the phrase “integrative medicine“) David Riley, MD and his team sent an electronic letter announcing that the team was resigning. I publish it here in full:

“Dear Alternative Therapies in Health
and Medicine s
upporters,



“The
editors of Alternative Therapies in Health and Medicine (ATHM) would
like to inform you – our colleagues – that the editorial team of David
Riley, Christine Girard, Jason Hao, and Michele Mittelman resigned as a group
from ATHM today. We have informed InnoVision
Professional Media (IVPM), previously InnoVision Health Media (IVHM) of our
decision. We are disappointed to be sending you this letter, so soon after
implementing new publication strategies earlier this year.




“On
July 1 of this year, American Securities Group and Healthy Directions
the former owners of InnoVision Health Media, elected to offer InnoVision Health
Media
(IVHM) to PMG data services owned and run by Dick Benson. PMG is a
service bureau that provides fulfillment
and circulation solutions to specialty publishers focusing on
consumer and business-to-business publications. Their clients have ranged
from Costco – a membership warehouse club to Lifetime Fitness – a national spa
and fitness chain. After working closely with Dick Benson and
observing his actions carefully for the past three months, we do not believe
that we share a common vision with PMG data services. We are
choosing to move forward in a different direction focusing on scholarly
rather than consumer publications.  

 

“After working closely with Dick Benson
and
observing his actions carefully for
the past three months we do not believe

that we share a common vision
with PMG data services.”

“We
believe that we have left Alternative Therapies in Health and Medicine in
a much stronger position than when we arrived: the inventory of accepted
manuscripts is significantly increased from less than 10 to more than 40
awaiting publication, journal editorial processes have been re-organized,
and IVPM has a hard-working editorial and production team in place. As an
editorial team we are particularly please with the July special issue on
Coherence and the September special issue on nursing, and the upcoming and
already edited November special issue on Chinese medicine.




“We
intend to move together as an editorial team with new initiatives in scholarly
publication.  As most of you know, Alternative Therapies in Health
and Medicine
 was the first scholarly publication indexed by the Nation
Library of Medicine and is the only professional journal published by IVPM to
have both an impact factor and be indexed. Our mission remains
to promote the art and science of integrative medicine and to improve patient
centered collaborations. We believe that the best way to do this is to maintain
the highest standards of peer review, producing scientific articles and news
that is timely, accurate, and a pleasure to read. We hope in the future to work
closely with each of you and continue to foster the ongoing debate about
the scientific, clinical, historical, legal, and policy issues that affect all
of health care and integrative medicine.


“As
we evaluate opportunities and options to continue to serve the community of
practitioners, health care students in integrative health care we will keep you
informed of our plans and hope to work with you as they unfold.  Feel free
to contact us if you have any further questions.




“Best
regards




“David
Riley [MD]  Christine Girard [ND] Jason Hao [LAc] Michele Mittleman [RN]”

Comment: This step puts an exclamation mark on Innovision’s slow walk back from Chapter 11 in November 2008, which led to the sale to Healthy Directions, the letting go of former vice president Frank Lampe and the “offering” to Benson and PMG. This news, because I know and respect the Riley-Girard-Mittleman team (I don’t know Hao), is a kick to both the head and stomach. Can we not support a quality peer-reviewed publication? I am not entirely disinterested: I write a column for Integrative Medicine: A Clinician’s Journal, also owned by PMG presently, and led by Joseph Pizzorno, ND. No news yet on whether there will be changes with that journal. Meantime, I look forward to hearing where Riley and his team go with their future publishing interests. 

 

Image

Hawk: Kicks off new online peer-reviewed journal

Call for Submissions: Peer-reviewed Topics in Integrative Health Care launched; Cheryl Hawk, DC, PhD editor in chief

Cheryl Hawk, DC, PhD, CHES sent this note September 17, 2010: “We’re very proud to announce the launch of
Topics in Integrative Health Care
(TIHC), a
peer-reviewed, open-access quarterly online journal.” The publication will focus on

“advancing the integration of multiple
disciplines, both complementary and mainstream, into diverse health care
settings in order to provide optimal patient care.” Hawk adds that the journal “will emphasize
not only the integration of various approaches and settings for the
treatment
of conditions, but also the integration of health promotion and
prevention into
all clinical encounters, as well as into both patients’ and providers’
daily
lives.” Hawk invites submissions to TIHC. The following themes are
tentatively scheduled for the
first volume (2010-2011): Winter 2010-Improving the Health of Older Adults; Spring 2011-Physical Activity and Sports/Leisure; and Summer 2011-Approaches to Body-Mind Health and Healing. Hawk’s welcoming comments in Volume 1, #1 are available here.

Comment: Hawk is a highly regarded and nationally-recognized chiropractic researcher in the chiropractic field who also serves on the multi-disciplinary Research Working Group of the Academic Consortium for Complementary and Alternative Health Care. She distinguishes herself from many by her depth involvement in wellness, serving as one of two DC leaders in a wellness certification program for chiropractors and participating as the one chiropractic representative at a recent summit on health coaching standards. The first issue is chiropractor-intensive as might be expected, yet the team’s editorial line is discipline-neutral and, given the subject matter, the team is actively seeking submissions from those from other disciplines.

 

Image

Rakel: Invites submissions for special issue

Call for Papers: Special issue on communication in complementary medicine in 2012 issue of Patient Education Counseling, Rakel to co-edit

David Rakel, MD invites submissions to a special issue in the peer-reviewed Patient Education Counseling planned for 2012 on “Communication in complementary medicine approaches in healthcare.” Rakel, an integrative medicine leader in family medicine at the University of Wisconsin, will co-edit the volume as part of an international team. He writes:

“This
theme issue will be wide open in regards to CAM and improving communication
among patients and professionals. It would be a great opportunity for
professionals from diverse CAM fields to share their insights on the topic.”

A note from the publisher, Elsevier, states that “the scope of
this special issue is not the state of art of complementary and
alternative medicine (CAM) interventions, but rather issues involved in several aspects of the communication about CAM, and especially complementary medicine (CM).” A list of possible topics is here.
All types of contributions are welcome: reviews, original empirical
work, qualitative papers, models for education and counseling, and
organization of CM. Short proposals are urged before December, 1 2010.


Conferences

Image

2011 event in New York, March 4-6

Integrative Healthcare
Symposium will be held on March 4-6, 2011 at the Hilton New York


Integrative Healthcare
Symposium
will be held on March 4-6, 2011 at the Hilton New York on
March 4th – 6th 2011. The event, which distinguishes itself by drawing an MD-focused but multidisciplinary group (MD, RN, DC, ND,
LAc, etc.) gathered 1100 practitioners in 2010. Program areas for
2011 are nutrition, integrative oncology, endocrinology, brain & mind health and leadership & policy.  Woodson Merrell, MD is the conference chair. Among the speakers
are
Rachel Remen, MD, Jeff Bland, PhD, Walter Crinnion, ND, Mark Hyman, MD, Nan Lu,
OMD, LAc,
David Perlmutter, MD, Lise
Alschuler, ND,
Ben Kligler, MD, Tierana Low Dog, MD, Alan Gaby, MD, Marcelle Pick, NP and more. (Disclosure: IHS is an 

Integrator sponsor and I assist the firm with its policy-related
content.)

Comment: Oh yeah, another speaker will be some fellow who writes an electronic newsletter. I’ll be offering a look at the year in review in integrative policy and practice. I’ll also moderate a separate panel on hospital-based integration, with Lori Knutson, RN, BS-HN, Kligler, and Richard Gannotta, NP, DHA. It’s a lively conference and gathering. Make it if you can!


People

Image

Elliott: Longtime exec honored in naming of building

Chiropractic examination group to honor long-time executive in dedicating the Horace C. Elliott Center

On November 5, 2010, the National Board of Chiropractic Examiners (NBCE)
will honor the organization’s long-time leader by dedicating the Horace C. Elliott Center on the organization’s Greeley, Colorado campus. Elliott has been NBCE’s leading executive since 1986. The
action by the NBCE board follows a series of significant honors Elliott
has received from chiropractic institutions and agencies.
The 15,000 square foot new conference facility will primarily be used
for test committee meetings and exam production and other meeting
functions. It contains state of the art meeting, sound and
teleconferencing technology.
Elliot also
serves on the Board of the Academic Consortium for Complementary and Alternative Health Care.

Image

Cohn: Honored with library naming

Tai Sophia names library after Sherman Cohn, JD

Tai Sophia Institute has dedicated and named its library after Sherman Cohn, JD. Cohn, a volunteer leader in the integrative health field, and
particularly for acupuncture and Oriental medicine, was honored by Tai
Sophia as “a longtime friend, supporter, generous
benefactor, Georgetown University law professor, and Tai Sophia’s Chairman of
the Board of Trustees.” The
Sherman L. Cohn Library is described as “by far the best
acupuncture library on the East Coast and maybe in the country.” The library is open to the public and is viewed as “a great
resource to the alternative medicine community and the residents of Howard
County and all of Maryland.” A newsletter from Tai Sophia spoke of the award as “a fitting tribute to name
this extraordinary place of education, research, study, and continued
enlightenment.” Cohn, a onetime Watergate lawyer, is a sometimes Integrator contributor.

 

Image

Haramati: Honored with educator award

Georgetown integrative leader Adi Haramati awarded Master Scholar Award by medical science educators group

The International Association of Medical Science Educators (IAMSE) has named Aviad “Adi” Haramati, PhD, professor of physiology and biophysics at Georgetown University School of Medicine,
as the winner of its Master Scholar Award according to an October 1, 2010 release.
The release notes that the award “recognizes an IAMSE member who has a
distinguished record of
educational scholarship, including educational research and/or
dissemination of excellent and scholarly approaches to teaching and
education.” Haramati, a founding member of IAMSE and its first
president, is a significant player in academic integrative medicine and
specifically in educational integration between those in conventional
academic health centers and those educators and institutions associated with the licensed
integrative practice disciplines. Haramati’s link between programs at Georgetown and Bastyr University,
noted elsewhere in this Round-up, was a featured in this recent Integrator article.

 

Send your comments to
johnweeks@theintegratorblog.com

for inclusion in a future Your Comments Forum.

]]>
5946